健康人人关心的话题分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/qpzeng 写“正能量”博客,做“富营养”科普

博文

“于艳茹事件”:国内人人喊打,国外鸦雀无声

已有 5813 次阅读 2014-8-25 06:52 |个人分类:名人轶事|系统分类:观点评述| 小保方晴子, 于艳茹

北京大学、女博士生、抄袭··· ···,这些“亮眼”的关键词瞬间吸引了全国各大媒体的高度关注,含这几个关键词的消息铺天盖地。不过,有新闻价值的报道基本上只有两篇(来自澎湃新闻的原创报道和来自中国青年报的后续报道),其他都属于疯狂转载,了无新意。

从报道的内容与读者的声音来看,几乎是清一色的愤怒、谴责和声讨,异口同声,共执一词,人人喊打之声不绝于耳,唯有我一人发出微弱的“噪音”。网友们不仅强烈要求查处于艳茹博士本人,而且还主张扳倒于艳茹在北大的博导,甚至追溯她在北师大的硕导。反观我的观点,昨天纠结于“抄袭”不等于“翻译或编译”,今天仍然固执己见,也许我是错的,但我仍坚持保留我的看法。

我记得,当“小保方晴子事件”发生后,全世界各大媒体都竞相报道,而对于“于艳茹事件”却一言不发,毫无反应。我分析,一方面,小保方晴子在Nature发表的论文具有国际影响力,而于艳茹的论文则发表在SCI、SSCI不收录的中文学术期刊上,当然不可同日而语。另一方面,日本RIKEN在事件发生后立即让小保方晴子亲自出面澄清,而无论北京大学、中社科院至今都没有安排于艳茹本人站出来发声。

在Google以Yu Yan-ru和plagiarism为关键词检索,竟然没有搜寻到一篇由世界知名报纸发出的新闻稿,倒是查到两篇疑似国内媒体的翻译稿,而且表述非常蹩脚,一看就是没有专业水准的人翻译的,我甚至怀疑就是机器人翻译的。


Peking University doctoral student in the Department of History Yan Ru traced to a large number of copying foreign papers

WASHINGTON ” international press ” recently published a ” plagiarism on tonotice “, ” notice ” that , inPh.D. in history from Peking University during the reading of the papers , ” 1775 French Masses’ News industry, ” Fronde ” ” suspected of serious plagiarism. Yesterday, the Beijing University history department official said , because inalready graduated , the department will organize experts to re- verification of their doctoral thesis , as verified plagiarism issues will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of the school. According to the North , if verified inplagiarized papers, their diploma, degree certificate will be revoked.

NPC teacher accidentally discovered plagiarism

August 17 , news media class renowned academic journal ” international press ” on its official website hung out a ” Yu Yan Ru plagiarism on notice .” “Announcement “, said journal readers recently received report on Yan Ru paper, ” 1775 French public journalism ” Fronde ” ” suspected of plagiarism.

By the editorial department carefully than right, in Yan Ru published in the journal in 2013 the first seven papers ” in 1775 the French public journalism ” Fronde “”, a large segment of the translation Nina R. Gelbart published in “Eighteenth-Century Studies ” section 4 of the 1984 paper ” “Frondeur” Journalism in the 1770s: Theater Criticism and Radical Politics in the Prerevolutionary French Press “, and even directly Gelbart references cited as a comment .

The announcement also provides a full two papers , and the yellow marked inspecific plagiarized content , multiple paragraphs or even the word has not changed , according to the original translation .

” International press ” editor, Professor School of Journalism , Renmin University of China Chen Lidan , this year in May , a teacher at the University of the Chinese People’s accidental discovery in the study of this paper insuspected plagiarism , and to ” the international press ,” the editorial board reflects this. Subsequently, the editorial department conducted a survey specifically looking for a foreign language original book , also invited foreign experts to check . By the end of June , ” the international press ,” the editorial department held a special meeting to decide how to proceed. Because of journal publishing cycle, announcement to August were announced.

North will verify at Yan Ru PhD thesis

Yesterday , the Department of History relevant responsible person said , inlast year graduated from Peking University , suspected of serious plagiarism issue against her during the Peking University History Department published doctoral thesis , the department will immediately organize experts to its PhD thesis re- verification , if plagiarism case , once verified, will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of the school.

According to ” Beijing University graduate basic academic norms ,” ” has ended and students left school after school , during school if there is a serious violation of academic norms of behavior , once verified , the revocation of the relevant reward its then obtained , diploma and degree certificates . ” Beiqing Bao reporter noted that the ” norms ” of the scope of application include ” the existence of academic misconducts during the reading has left school graduate . “

It is understood that in the history of Beijing Normal Universityhistory of the world of professional master’s degree graduates in the 2006 session , in September 2008 admitted to Peking University , Department of History , read a doctorate. September 2011 , in Yan Ru as the 2011 Peking ” Ph.D. short-term abroad (Habitat ) Research Project ” ( second batch ) funding target , went to Harvard University exchange four months. July 2013 , Dr. Yu Yanru after graduation to enter the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Institute of World History postdoctoral . When accused of plagiarism of papers published inHistory Department of Peking University doctoral students in reading .

” The international press ,” the first issue of plagiarism Announcement

Chen Lidan said that as academic journals , had ” international press ” also dealt with the problem of plagiarism several times , but mostly internal processing , the first time issued a notice on the plagiarism issue . The reason why this will be made public , Chen Lidan explained that this is because inof this paper is the most serious cases of plagiarism a journal currently experiencing .

Chen Lidan that is not easy to expose academic plagiarism , copying sections of a very small chance of being found from the foreign language books , the editorial department is difficult to avoid this from happening , “Some part of the article with the others but did not indicate the source of the article , this does not belong to the academic standards, our internal process , instructing him to apologize , three years does not send his manuscript , known online electronic version removed from China , will not be disclosed . ” but inthis is ” the international press . ” plagiarism is currently experiencing the most serious one, “In addition to a few feeds and final conclusion , almost all copied ! wording is identical , comments are to move over ! ” Chen Lidan said.

As for how to deal with after the announcement, Chen Lidan believe that this should be decided by the relevant units themselves. ” Announcement” that ” international press ” will contact the relevant literature collection agency to delete the electronic version of the text , and the refusal of submission tofive years , and plagiarism briefing their respective units. Peking University Department of History Professor Luo new name authentication microblogging in fact , said : “This whole system should also notice , make known salty smell .”

But as of 9:00 last night , in Yan Ru ‘s this ” 1775 French public journalism ” Fronde ” ” is still in the ” Chinese HowNet ” search .

Original link: http://news.163.com/14/0824/02/A4CLEARD00014AED.html

This entry was posted in Community on August 24, 2014 by .



Peking University doctoral dissertation alleged plagiarism incident investigation
The international press, recently published an About Yu Yan Ru plagiarism announcement
Announcement that, in the Department of History Dr. 艳茹 during the reading of the papers, in 1775 the French public journalism Fronde suspected of serious plagiarism. Yesterday, the Beijing University history department official said, because in 艳茹 already graduated, the department will organize experts to re-verification of their doctoral thesis, as verified plagiarism issues will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of the school. According to the North, if verified in 艳茹 plagiarized papers, their diploma, degree certificate will be revoked.
Yu Yan Ru paper in 1775 the French public journalism Fronde text in the first one, marked by yellow plagiarism content.
(Reporter Dong Xin) international press recently published an About Yu Yan Ru plagiarism announcement
Announcement that, in the Department of History Dr. 艳茹 during the reading of the papers, in 1775 the French public journalism Fronde suspected of serious plagiarism. Yesterday, the Beijing University history department official said, because in 艳茹 already graduated, the department will organize experts to re-verification of their doctoral thesis, as verified plagiarism issues will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of the school. According to the North, if verified in 艳茹 plagiarized papers, their diploma, degree certificate will be revoked.
NPC teacher accidentally discovered plagiarism

August 17, news media class renowned academic journal international press on its official website hung out a Yu Yan Ru plagiarism on notice. Announcement, said journal readers recently received report on Yan Ru paper, 1775 French public journalism Fronde suspected of plagiarism.
By the editorial department carefully than right, in Yan Ru published in the journal in 2013 the first seven papers in 1775 the French public journalism Fronde , a large segment of the translation Nina R.
Gelbart published in the Eighteenth-Century Studies 1984 on the four papers Frondeur
APT is difficult to prevent, but to strengthen the monitoring of employee network behavior regarded as one of the measures, the problem is to find out from the mass of data in APT clues and valuable information is not easy.
Journalism in the 1770s: Theater Criticism and Radical Politics in the Prerevolutionary French Press , or even directly Gelbart references cited as a comment.
The announcement also provides a full two papers, and the yellow marked in 艳茹 specific plagiarized content, multiple paragraphs or even the word has not changed, according to the original translation.
The international press.
Editor, journalism professor at Renmin University of China Chen Lidan, this year in May, a teacher at the University of the Chinese People's accidental discovery in the study of this paper in 艳茹 suspected plagiarism, and to the international press, the editorial board reflects this thing. Subsequently, the editorial department conducted a survey specifically looking for a foreign language original book, also invited foreign experts to check. By the end of June, the international press, the editorial department held a special meeting to decide how to proceed. Because of journal publishing cycle, announcement to August were announced.
The use of social networks in the workplace should be more careful, the enemy war commercial areas now far better than military war, social media and the user wants to strengthen information security awareness.
North will verify at Yan Ru PhD thesis
Yesterday, the Department of History relevant responsible person said, in 艳茹 last year graduated from Peking University, suspected of serious plagiarism issue against her during the Peking University History Department published doctoral thesis, the department will immediately organize experts to its PhD thesis re-verification, if plagiarism case, once verified, will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of the school.
According to Beijing University graduate basic academic norms, has ended and students left school after school, during school if there is a serious violation of academic norms of behavior, once verified, the revocation of the relevant reward its then obtained, diploma and degree certificates . Beiqing Bao reporter noted that the norms of the scope of application include the existence of academic misconducts during the reading has left school graduate.
It is understood that in the history of Beijing Normal University 艳茹 history of the world of professional master's degree graduates in the 2006 session, in September 2008 admitted to Peking University, Department of History, read a doctorate. September 2011,
Yu Yan Ru as the 2011 Peking Ph.D. short-term abroad (Habitat) Research Project (second batch) funding target, went to Harvard University exchange four months. July 2013, Dr. Yu Yanru after graduation to enter the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Institute of World History postdoctoral. When accused of plagiarism of papers published in 艳茹 History Department of Peking University doctoral students in reading.
The international press, the first issue of plagiarism Announcement
Chen Lidan said that as academic journals, had international press also dealt with the problem of plagiarism several times, but mostly internal processing, the first time issued a notice on the plagiarism issue. The reason why this will be made public, Chen Lidan explained that this is because in 艳茹 of this paper is the most serious cases of plagiarism a journal currently experiencing.

Chen Lidan that is not easy to expose academic plagiarism, copying sections of a very small chance of being found from the foreign language books, the editorial department is difficult to avoid this from happening, Some part of the article with the others but did not indicate the source of the article, This does not belong to the academic standards, our internal process, instructing him to apologize, three years does not send his manuscript, known online electronic version removed from China, will not be disclosed. But in 艳茹 this is the international press. Plagiarism is currently experiencing the most serious one, In addition to a few feeds and final conclusion, almost all copied! wording is identical, comments are to move over! Chen Lidan said.
As for how to deal with after the announcement, Chen Lidan believe that this should be decided by the relevant units themselves. Announcement that international press will contact the relevant literature collection agency to delete the electronic version of the text, and the refusal of submission to 艳茹 five years, and plagiarism briefing their respective units. Peking University Department of History Professor Luo new name authentication microblogging in fact, said: This whole system should also notice, make known salty smell.
But as of 9:00 last night, in Yan Ru's this 1775 French public journalism Fronde is still in the Chinese HowNet search.




学术不端
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-281238-822065.html

上一篇:于艳茹的论文不能认定为“抄袭”
下一篇:中医之我见(3)“阴阳学说”今解
收藏 IP: 61.144.26.*| 热度|

4 吕喆 文克玲 rosejump chaijf

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (8 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2025-1-11 02:56

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部