博文
相反微波吸收理论比较
||
这两个理论
现行微波吸收的主流理论和微波吸收的波动力学理论
是水火不容的两个相对立的理论，
只能是：
一个是错误的理论，
而另一个是正确的理论。
错误的理论从任何角度看，都是错的，
正确的理论从任何角度看，都是正确的。
自说自话、不提对方观点，不能视做反击，
只能看成：对反方观点不屑一顾、不拿正眼看你。
历史的结论：
究竟哪个理论是错误的？哪个是正确的？
...
(拭目以待 ...)
1 现行微波吸收的主流理论
著名博导 电磁波微波吸收-概述说明以及解释.pdf-原创力文档
2024-12-08 发布于河南
===================================================
点评：
主流微波吸收理论的一个特点是：用材料的微波吸收解释膜的微波吸收峰。
但是膜和材料的微波吸收根本就是两码事。
因此国际上，我国的微波吸收论文发的最多，发表的期刊档次最高，
专家们拿了大量的项目研究经费，
但是除了与顶刊编辑的关系搞得好之外，
我国的飞机隐身技术并不隐身。
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chphma.2022.10.002
专家们借口这样那样的瓶颈无法突破，
但是专家们根本不提为什么他们的微波吸收理论的错误无法突破。
基本理论错了，技术突破从哪里来？
基础研究水平才是技术发展的源动力。
连大学本科波叠加原理都搞不清楚的专家，
虽然他们有大量的研究经费的支持，
你能指望他们搞出什么技术名堂来？
只要搞懂大学本科的波叠加原理，
就能搞清楚：
现行主流微波吸收理论正确，
还是
新建立的微波吸收的波动力学理论正确。
上海交通大学杨枫教授：如果学术界是个草台班子，那就一定有草包
----------------------------------
只要你敢于站在主流理论的对立面分析问题，颠覆性创新的灵感就会神奇地经常光顾你的大脑
===========================================
科学网—NML文章集锦 | 微波吸收与电磁屏蔽 - 纳微快报的博文
微波吸收材料（吸收微波、电磁反射与散射较小的材料）_百度百科
=========================================
2 反方理论：微波吸收的波动力学理论
被大量实验文章实证的现行微波吸收理论错的如此彻底，其逻辑错误无法修复
推翻现行微波吸收理论是系列工作，其结果的发表一寸一寸地取得进展
Qeios预印本平台对SCI二区顶刊的一篇微波吸收论文的评论的YouTube视频介绍
Qeios预印本平台的微波吸收纠错论文的YouTube视频介绍
Questions from Acaudio (with answers attached)
Fundamental theory of microwave absorption for films
现行微波吸收理论混淆了膜和材料的区别（公开的学术擂台，接受挑战）
==============
======================
3 反方相关论文
1. Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Review: 膜微波吸收研究在波动力学理论方向的新进展, 分子科学学报(英文版, Journal of Molecular Science), 2024, 40(198-04), 300 -305; Review of Wave Mechanics Theory for Microwave Absorption by Film, Qeios, Preprint, 2024-07-04, Supplementary data
2. Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Review: Recognizing Problems in Publications Concerned with Microwave Absorption Film and Providing Corrections: A Focused Review, Qeios, preprin, 2024-07-01, Supplementary data, Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB, [Commentary] Comments on: “A perspective on impedance matching and resonance absorption mechanism for electromagnetic wave absorbing” by Hou et al. [Carbon 222 (2024) 118935], Qeios, 2024, Supplementary Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB, Corrections of common errors in current theories of microwave absorption caused by confusing film and material, Qeios, 2024/02/10, preprint, https://doi.org/10.32388/QQ1MFF; Corrections of Common Errors Associated with the Confusion between Film and Material in Current Theories of Microwave Absorption. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4797207 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4797207
3. Yue Liu，Ying Liu，Michael G. B Drew. Review：Wave mechanics of microwave absorption in films: a short review, Optics and Laser Technology, 2024, 178, 111211 （The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film-Part 1: A short review, Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, scite）
4. Yue Liu，Ying Liu，Michael G. B Drew，Wave Mechanics of Microwave Absorption in Films - Distinguishing Film from Material，Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials，2024， 593, 171850 ; ( The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film – Part 2: The difference between film and material，Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, Supplementarial file)
5. Yue Liu，Ying Liu，Michael G. B Drew，Wave Mechanics of Microwave Absorption in Films: Multilayered Films, Journal of Electronic Materials, 2024, doi: 10.1007/s11664-024-11370-9; The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film-Part 3: Film with multilayers, Preprint, Research Square, 13 Aug, 2023,Supplementarial file, scite_
6. Yue Liu, Michael G. B Drew,Ying Liu, A Theoretical Exploration of Impedance Matching Coefficients for Interfaces and Films, Applied Physics A, 2024, 130, 212
7. Ying Liu, Michael. G.B. Drew, Yue Liu, Chapter 4: Fundamental Theory of Microwave Absorption for Films of Porous Nanocomposites: Role of Interfaces in Composite-Fillers, in Porous Nanocomposites for Electromagnetic Interference Shielding, Edited by: Sabu Thomas, Claudio Paoloni, Avinash R. Pai, 2024, Elsevier, [978-0-323-90035-5_B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1], pp. 59 - 90, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1
8. 刘颖， 刘跃，膜的微波吸收机理， 分子科学学报， 2023，v.39; No.194(06) 521-527
9. Ying Liu, Kaiqi Yang, Yue Liu, Michael G. B Drew, The Shackles of Peer Review: Unveiling the Flaws in the Ivory Tower, arXiv, https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2310.05966
10. Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, A physics investigation on impedance matching theory in microwave absorption film—Part 1: Theory, Journal of Applied Physics, 2023, 134(4), 045303, DOI: 10.1063/5.0153608
11. Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, A physics investigation on impedance matching theory in microwave absorption film—Part 2: Problem Analyses, Journal of Applied Physics, 2023, 134(4), 045304, DOI: 10.1063/5.0153612
12. Ying Liu; Xiangbin Yin; M. G. B. Drew; Yue Liu, Microwave absorption of film explained accurately by wave cancellation theory, Physica B: Condensed Matter, 2023, 666, 415108. (Microwave absorption of film explained accurately by wave cancellation theory, 2023-02-23 | Preprint, Research Square, DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-2616469/v2，Supplementary information: Available comments and our responses.)
13. Ying Liu, Yi Ding, Yue Liu, Michael G. B. Drew. Unexpected Results in Microwave Absorption – Part 1: Different absorption mechanisms for metal-backed film and for material, Surfaces and Interfaces, 2023, 40, 103022
14. Ying Liu, Yi Ding, Yue Liu, Michael G. B. Drew. Unexpected Results in Microwave Absorption – Part 2:. Angular effects and the wave cancellation theory, Surfaces and Interfaces, 2023, 40, 103024
15. Ying Liu, Xiangbin Yin, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, Reflection Loss is a Parameter for Film, not Material, Non-Metallic Material Science, 2023, 5(1): 38-48.
16. 刘颖，丁一，陈庆阳，刘跃，NiFe2-xMxO4 (M: Ce/Sm/Gd)的制备及其膜的微波吸收性能，沈阳师范大学学报 ( 自然科学版 ), 2023, 41(2)，98 - 103
17. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film – Part 1: Energy conservation, Mater. Chem. Phys. 2022, 290,126576.
18. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film – Part 2: The Real mechanism, Mater. Chem. Phys,. 2022, 291, 126601.
19. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film Part 3: Inverse relationship, Mater. Chem. Phys. 2022, 290, 126521.
20. Liu Y, Liu Y, Drew MGB. A theoretical investigation of the quarter-wavelength model — part 2: verification and extension. Physica Scripta 2022, 97(1) : 015806.
21. Liu Y, Liu Y, Drew MGB. A theoretical investigation on the quarter-wavelength model — part 1: analysis. Physica Scripta 2021, 96(12) : 125003. ( The problems in the quarter-wavelength model and impedance matching theory in analysising microwave absorption material, 2021-08-30 | Preprint, Research Square, DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-206241/v1)
22. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Li H, Liu Y. A theoretical analysis of the relationships shown from the general experimental results of scattering parameters s11 and s21 – exemplified by the film of BaFe12-iCeiO19/polypyrene with i = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6. Journal of Microwave Power and Electromagnetic Energy 2021, 55(3) : 197-218.
23. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Li H, Liu Y. An experimental and theoretical investigation into methods concerned with “reflection loss” for microwave absorbing materials. Materials Chemistry and Physics 2020, 243 : 122624.
24. Liu Y, Lin Y, Zhao K, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Microwave absorption properties of Ag/NiFe2-xCexO4 characterized by an alternative procedure rather than the main stream method using “reflection loss”. Materials Chemistry and Physics 2020, 243 : 122615
25. 赵坤 , 林雨冉 , 刘颖 . 微波吸收复合材料 Ag/NiFe2-xCexO4 的制备与表征. 功能材料 2020, 51(03) : 03171 - 03175.
26. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Characterization microwave absorption from active carbon/BaSmxFe12−xO19/polypyrrole composites analyzed with a more rigorous method. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2019, 30(2) : 1936-1956.
27. Yang K, Liu Y, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Preparation and characterization of BaSmxFe12 − xO19/polypyrrole composites. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2018, 29(15) : 13148-13160, Electronic supplementary material.
28. Liu Y, Zhao K, Drew MGB, Liu Y. A theoretical and practical clarification on the calculation of reflection loss for microwave absorbing materials. AIP Advances 2018, 8(1) : 015223.
29. Liu Y, Yu H, Drew MGB, Liu Y. A systemized parameter set applicable to microwave absorption for ferrite based materials. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2018, 29(2) : 1562-1575,Supplementary material.
30. Liu Y, Tai R, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Several Theoretical Perspectives of Ferrite-Based Materials—Part 1: Transmission Line Theory and Microwave Absorption. Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism 2017, 30(9) : 2489-2504.
31. Liu Y, Jin J, B. Drew MG, Liu Y. Several Theoretical Perspectives of Ferrite-Based Materials—Part 2: Close Packing Model for Crystal Structure. Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism 2017, 30(10) : 2777-2789.
32. Liu Y, Liu Y, Yin H, Drew MGB. Several Theoretical Perspectives of Ferrite-Based Materials-Part 3: Crystal Structure and Synthesis. Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism 2017, 30(11) : 3019-3025.
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-3589443-1464666.html
上一篇：也谈科学和技术
下一篇：[转载]顶刊和论文工厂之间的黑幕被实锤
