武夷山分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/Wuyishan 中国科学技术发展战略研究院研究员;南京大学信息管理系博导

博文

对国际科学计量学与信息计量学学会2003年北京大会一份会议投稿摘要的审理意见(2002年11月1日)

已有 1051 次阅读 2023-5-31 10:17 |个人分类:科学计量学研究|系统分类:观点评述

对国际科学计量学与信息计量学学会2003年北京大会一份会议投稿摘要的审理意见(2002年11月1日)

武夷山

 

REVIEWER REPORT FOR ISSI ONLY (Written comments for the ISSI Selection Panel)

Title: (略)

This might be the most comprehensive summary of various web indicators so far. The author (s) must be working like a horse collecting so much data and doing in depth analysis. The theoretical framework is not introduced in the abstract, but I hope it would be interesting. The author should pay some attention to his or her grammar.

 

REVIEWER REPORT FOR AUTHOR (comments to be made available to authors)

Title: (略)  

The author(s) has paid great effort to collect valuable data, present a theoretical framework and conduct empirical analysis. This hard labor should be appreciated.

Two points for consideration by the author:

1.  The Conclusion says that “ (t)he sample analyzed probably represents more than 95% of the world universities.” But how could the author ensure this is a correct estimate? In some developing countries, not every university has its own website. Beijing is one of the most advanced cities in China, but even in Beijing, not every institution of higher learning owns a website. Maybe the safe expression is“ 95% of the universities with websites”?

2.  The author should better check the grammatical correctness of the paper more carefully. In the abstract, there are some errors. In line 2 of the Introduction, “basic” should be “basis”.  In line 7, “use” should be “used”. In line 11, “others” be “other’. In line 5 of Method, “being” should be deleted. In line 1 of Result, “an related research institutes” should be “and related…”?         

 

 




https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-1557-1390018.html

上一篇:美国加州一名音响工程师的哲思(183)
下一篇:参加一个座谈会——日记摘抄1033
收藏 IP: 1.202.114.*| 热度|

1 杨正瓴

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-3-29 16:22

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部