许培扬博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/xupeiyang 跟踪国际前沿 服务国内科研

博文

2010年诺贝尔奖得主预测(4)全球反响与评论

已有 3942 次阅读 2010-9-22 08:21 |个人分类:科技评价|系统分类:论文交流| 预测, 诺贝尔奖

 

 2010年诺贝尔奖得主预测

 

21位“引文桂冠得主”有望角逐诺贝尔奖

 

 
9月21日,汤森路透(Thomson Reuters)率先公布2010年引文桂冠的得主名单,他们将有望角逐诺贝尔奖的殊荣。这些备受全球瞩目的研究奖项的获得者即将在两周后揭晓。
 

 http://news.sciencenet.cn//htmlnews/2010/9/237853.shtm

 

Can the winners of the Nobel Prize be correctly predicted?

http://science.thomsonreuters.com/nobel/

  • 2010 Predictions
  • http://science.thomsonreuters.com/nobel/2010predictions/

    Nobel hopefuls by the numbers

    http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57694/

     

    News:
    Nobel hopefuls by the numbers
    Posted by Bob Grant
    [Entry posted at 21st September 2010 03:42 PM GMT]

    The researcher who developed induced pluripotent stem cells, the biochemist who invented DNA microarrays, and the immunologist who discovered dendritic cells are just a few of the scientists whose citation records are robust enough to attract a Nobel Prize this year, according to Thomson Reuters, the company that manages the Web of Science citation indexing tool -- brainchild of The Scientist founder Eugene Garfield. The company released their 2010 Nobel Prize predictions today (21st September).


    For the past 8 years, Thomson Reuters, has thrown its hat into the ring, publishing the names of "Citation Laureates" -- a list of researchers that are potential recipients of that year's Nobel Prizes, based on an analysis of 30 years of citation counts. Thomson Reuters citation analyst David Pendlebury performs these calculations, and is in charge of putting the list together every year. "I'm always hopeful, and yet I'm usually surprised if we get any right because of the statistical improbability of doing this," he said of the exercise. "Ultimately what were trying to do is show that there is a meaning to citations in the literature and they correspond to subjective measure of quality and esteem in science."

    Though Pendlebury admits that it's "almost miraculous that we ever get anybody right," his prediction formula -- which also considers factors, such as other prestigious prizes (Lasker, Kyoto, etc.) researchers have recently won, and whether a particular discovery is of the type typically recognized by the Nobel committees -- has struck gold in recently. Last year, Thomson Reuters correctly predicted that Elizabeth Blackburn, Carol Greider, and Jack Szostak would win the prize in Physiology or Medicine for their discovery of the enzyme telomerase and how telomeres protect chromosomes. And in 2008, Thomson Reuters Citation Laureate Roger Tsien became a Nobel Laureate for the discovery and development of the ubiquitous green fluorescent protein (though Thomson Reuters failed to name Tsien's co-awardees Osamu Shimomura and Martin Chalfie, who contributed to the discovery).

    Without further ado, here are the 2010 Thomson Reuters Citation Laureates whose accomplishments are pertinent to the life sciences, listed by field:

    Chemistry:

    - Patrick Brown, Stanford University biochemist, "for the invention and application of DNA microarrays, a revolutionary tool in the study of variations in gene expression."

    - Stephen Lippard, Massachusetts Institute of Technology chemist, "for pioneering research in bioinorganic chemistry, including the discovery of metallointercalators to disrupt DNA replication, an important contribution to improved cancer therapy."

    Physiology or Medicine:

    - Douglas Coleman, Jackson Laboratory senior staff scientist emeritus, and Jeffrey Friedman, Rockefeller University molecular geneticist, "for the discovery of leptin, a hormone regulating appetite and metabolism."

    - Ernest McCulloch and James Till, both senior scientists at the Ontario Cancer Institute, and Shinya Yamanaka, Kyoto University and University of California, San Francisco, stem cell researcher, "for the discovery of stem cells and the development of induced pluripotent stem cells."

    - Ralph Steinman, Rockefeller University immunologist, "for the discovery of dendritic cells, key regulators of immune response."
       


    Jeffrey Friedman, who Thomson Reuters tapped as a potential winner of this year's Physiology or Medicine Prize, told The Scientist that it was "cool" that he was named in the company's predictions, but added that he doesn't really pay much attention to such hubbub. "I like what I do, and just try to keep my head down," he said.

    As the research community's gaze begins to shift towards Stockholm, where in two weeks a new class of Nobel Laureates will join the annals of science history, stay tuned to The Scientist. We'll be covering any more predictions that crop up, and we'll provide instant reports, reactions, and analysis when the science Nobels are announced in the first week of October.

    Related stories:
  • Opinion: A fishy Nobel Prize
    [10th December 2009]
  • Telomere researchers win Nobel
    [5th October 2009]
  • 2009 Nobel predictions go public
    [25th September 2009]


  • Read more: Nobel hopefuls by the numbers - The Scientist - Magazine of the Life Sciences http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57694/#ixzz10DHExyEw

     

     全球反响与评论




    Nobel Hopefuls
    by Mike Waldrep

    [Comment posted 2010-09-21 16:46:31]
    Interesting!



    duh
    by anonymous poster

    [Comment posted 2010-09-21 15:54:16]


    The only intelligent statement in this entire article is the quote from Jeffrey Friedman.

    Dr. Friedman sounds like a mensch.



    Predictions should be secret
    by Jim Clark

    [Comment posted 2010-09-21 13:09:37]
    Hi

    Properly, the predictions should be kept secret until the Nobel announcements are made since making predictions public could influence the results. Also, wouldn't post-dictions do just as well to test out meaningfulness of citation indices?

    Take care
    Jim



    Overdue for stem cell discovery
    by anonymous poster

    [Comment posted 2010-09-21 12:58:17]
    It is hard to imagine and understand how after nearly fifty years Ernest McCulloch and James Till have not yet been awarded the Nobel Prize for discovering stem cells. Their work ultimately led to a revolution in scientific and clinical study. Leukemia became treatable for the first time through the knowledge they provided. Their pioneering contributions ultimately led to the cancer stem cell hypothesis. I wish them the very best and hope that their significance is recognized by other laureates.




    Comment on this news story


    Read more: Nobel hopefuls by the numbers - The Scientist - Magazine of the Life Sciences http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57694/#comments#ixzz10DHzO0FI

     

    2010年诺贝尔奖科学奖项揭晓日期确定

    http://news.sciencenet.cn/htmlnews/2010/9/237857.shtm

     

     

     



    https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-280034-365552.html

    上一篇:声援支持方舟子 从速审判肖传国
    下一篇:Douglas L. Coleman的论文被引用情况(2010年生理学或医学诺贝尔奖得主预测)
    收藏 IP: .*| 热度|

    1 孙学军

    发表评论 评论 (0 个评论)

    数据加载中...
    扫一扫,分享此博文

    Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

    GMT+8, 2024-5-13 22:43

    Powered by ScienceNet.cn

    Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

    返回顶部