jianweihan的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/jianweihan

博文

有机化学的挑战:今天读了一个Derek Lowe的blog,他说的太对了

已有 4211 次阅读 2011-2-4 15:28 |系统分类:科研笔记| 有机化学

他写了一个帖子Organic Chemistry: A Lack of Challenges?(有机化学,缺乏挑战?)

有机化学发展到今天,每人都在JACS,ACIE上灌水,好似有机化学都很精彩,一个复杂的分子可以很精确的合成出来,难道有机化学没挑战么?恰恰不是,而是挑战太大。。

I worry a lot about organic chemistry, about the state of the discipline. I worry about the relative lack of grand challenges, and that most academic work is highly incremental and, worse, almost entirely the result of screening rather than design. There is still so little predictive power (at least in academia) in drug or catalyst discovery. I have a theory that the reason we're so brutal with each other in paper and grant refereeing is because we're essentially dogs under the table fighting for scraps.(我担心有机化学很多,尤其是学科目前的状况我担心有机化学重大挑战相对缺乏,但是学术论文数量在迅速增加,可笑的是,几乎完全是在筛选结果, 而并非基于化学原理的设计我们对于发现新药或催化剂的预测力如此有限(至少在学术界)认为,在审稿论文和基金判定时,我们却互相瞧不起对方的工作或计划,恰恰说明我们就像饭桌下面乞讨残羹冷饭的狗那样可怜。博主译)

There are big exceptions, which make me excited to be a scientist. There's usually something in Nature Chemistry that has the wow factor, for example. They're just so rare. . .



https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-535062-410226.html

上一篇:CC发表一篇有意思的文章:叔胺溶剂 -通过二氧化碳改变亲水性
下一篇:看到一篇好的文献,认识一个牛人:Edwin Vedejs
收藏 IP: 130.54.130.*| 热度|

5 李学宽 陈辉 杨华磊 樊采薇 yangzhu521

发表评论 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

全部作者的精选博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-5-19 08:02

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部