Bobby的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/Bobby

博文

穆勒对英国人的批评

已有 2381 次阅读 2013-2-5 15:40 |个人分类:科学感想|系统分类:人文社科| 英国人

 

每个国家的第一流知识分子都几乎对本国人都有批评,如卢梭对法国人的批评(以前我从《忏悔录》中摘过一段,但现在博文查不到),鲁迅对中国人的批评,现在我又从约翰·斯图尔特·穆勒( John Stuart Mill )的《我的知识之路》(Autobiography of John Stuart Mill)看到一段对英国人的批评,如英国人的情感不外露,缺乏与别人交流,对公共事务不关心等。

 

Having so little experience of English life, and the few people I knew being mostly such as had public objects, of a large and personally disinterested kind, at heart, I was ignorant of the low moral tone of what, in England, is called society'. the habit of, not indeed professing, but taking for granted in every mode of implication, that conduct is of course always directed towards low and petty objects; the absence of high feelings which manifests itself by sneering depreciation of all demonstrations of them, and by general abstinence (except among a few of the stricter religionists) from professing any high principles of action at all, except in those preordained cases in which such profession is put on as part of the costume and formalities of the occasion. I could not then know or estimate the difference between this manner of existence, and that of a people like the French, whose faults, if equally real, are at all events different; among whom sentiments, which by comparison at least may be called elevated, are the current coin of human intercourse, both in books and in private life; and though often evaporating in profession, are yet kept alive in the nation at large by constant exercise, and stimulated by sympathy, so as to form a living and active part of the existence of great numbers of persons, and to be recognized and understood by all. Neither could I then appreciate the general culture of the understanding, which results from the habitual exercise of the feelings, and is thus carried down into the most uneducated classes of several countries on the Continent, in a degree not equalled in England among the so-called educated, except where an unusual tenderness of conscience leads to a habitual exercise of the intellect on questions of right and wrong. I did not know the way in which, among the ordinary English, the absence of interest in things of an unselfish kind, except occasionally in a special thing here and there, and the habit of not speaking to others, nor much even to themselves, about the things in which they do feel interest, causes both their feelings and their intellectual faculties to remain undeveloped, or to develope themselves only in some single and very limited direction; reducing them, considered as spiritual beings, to a kind of negative existence. All these things I did not perceive till long afterwards; but I even then felt, though without stating it clearly to myself, the contrast between the frank sociability and amiability of French personal intercourse, and the English mode of existence in which everybody acts as if everybody else (with few, or no exceptions) was either an enemy or a bore. In France, it is true, the bad as well as the good points, both of individual and of national character, come more to the surface, and break out more fearlessly in ordinary intercourse, than in England: but the general habit of the people is to show, as well as to expect, friendly feeling in every one towards every other, wherever there is not some positive cause for the opposite. In England it is only of the best bred people, in the upper or upper middle ranks, that anything like this can be said.”(FROMAutobiography of John Stuart Mill

 



https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-39731-659738.html

上一篇:有一些吵架可以不掺乎
下一篇:真相和评价
收藏 IP: 150.255.15.*| 热度|

1 钟炳

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-7-3 11:22

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部