DFLISWX的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/DFLISWX

博文

本科生论文该不该抽检? 精选

已有 5928 次阅读 2023-11-22 06:20 |系统分类:观点评述

近年本科生论文抽检,研究生论文抽检似乎成了学生培养质量检查的必要措施。事实果真如此吗?

当前対研究生论文质量的诟病已经吵得沸沸扬扬,又要对本科生论文抽检,难道抽检真的能提升论文质量吗?我认为本科生论文抽检毫无意义,甚至本科生论文应该取消。

本科生以学习专业知识为主。毕业取决于课程学习的成绩而不是毕业论文。能受到基本的科研训练就已经不易了,何谈毕业论文高质量?何况现在从大三开始,本科生就把精力投入实习和找工作,根本没有时间认真做论文。本科生论文纯属拿鸭子上架,劳民伤财,师生心里彼此都心照不宣,走过场而已,何必当真?多数本科生论文大都是抄袭或者做点实验数据而已,根本没有什么含金量,对学生也没有提升科研能力的效果。老师们对带本科生论文也苦不堪言。

建议少数优秀本科生可以参加创新项目或结合本专业社会调查,写一篇调查报告或者综述即可,没必要一刀切做论文。毕业论文也不应该成为能否获得学位的依据。有科研兴趣或潜力的本科生可以考研,而多数本科生能就业就可以了。

提升本科生质量重在课程。希望学校把重视教学落到实处。老师上不好课,学生学习不到位,做论文无非给人以形式上的假象,自欺欺人。

抽检的结果无非就是放水或取消学位。但庞大的本科生群体让严格把关的老师只能放水,实属无奈。不知制定本科生抽检政策的领导们是否了解本科生论文现状?揠苗助长到头来事与愿违,画虎不成反类犬。




https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-729911-1410549.html

上一篇:地方院校的保送生
下一篇:关于77级属于哪届的疑问
收藏 IP: 183.63.102.*| 热度|

16 宁利中 段含明 汪凯 姚伟 刘秀梅 李涛 徐芳 崔锦华 汪运山 梁洪泽 褚海亮 温斌 王成玉 张鹏 guest52215631 550W

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (13 个评论)

IP: 113.140.11.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [8]寮犻   2017-8-30 10:42
  
IP: 222.219.184.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [7]biofans   2017-8-10 13:19
IBC2017
Title:
Deconstructing the Plant Regulatory Genome: Enabling Technologies
IP: 222.219.184.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [6]biofans   2017-8-10 13:16
ZT
Dr. Joseph Ecker is a Professor of Plant Molecular and Cellular Biology Laboratory and Director of the Genomic Analysis Laboratory at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies. He is also an Investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute and Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. Prof. Ecker holds the Salk International Council Chair in Genetics. For nearly 25 years, Dr. Ecker has been at the forefront of research to decode the genome of Arabidopsis thaliana, a mustard weed that has become the gold standard of plant research. He was a leader of the international effort to sequence all of Arabidopsis which was completed in 2000. More recently, Dr. Ecker has turned to deciphering the epigenome, the layer of molecular tweaks that act on DNA to turn genes on and off. The genetic reference books developed by Ecker and his colleagues may have enormous practical uses in crop engineering. This work is also showing that the complicated genetic underpinnings of plants and humans are more similar than common perception. Dr. Ecker has received a number of honors for his notable contributions to the field of plant biology. In a study TIME magazine ranked Dr. Ecker and his team鈥檚 work to provide the first detailed map of the human genome, as the second most important scientific discovery of 2009. In 2011, he received the George W. Beadle Medal for his outstanding contributions to the genetics community. His other accolades include National Academy of Sciences, John J. Carty Award for the Advancement of Science; the Martin Gibbs Medal; the International Plant Growth Substances Association Distinguished Research Award; and the Kumho Science International Award in Plant Molecular Biology.
IP: 117.151.49.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [5]鏅忔垚鍜�   2017-7-29 10:46
涓€涓満姊板伐绋嬪笀銆佹暀甯堬紝鍐欎簡鍑犲崄绡囩墿鐞嗗鍘熷垱鍗氬锛屾槸涓嶆槸璺ㄧ晫锛�
IP: 58.213.152.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [4]钄″皬瀹�   2017-7-28 15:09
  
IP: 183.144.210.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [3]zjzhaokeqin   2017-7-28 10:30
鑱旂郴鏄垱鏂颁箣婧�http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-329317-853956.html
IP: 116.22.184.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [2]鏇炬澃   2017-7-28 09:53
鍗充娇澶у涓€涓敓鐗╁鏁欐巿杩涘叆浼佷笟锛屽鏋滀粛鐒舵槸鍋氭妧鏈柟闈㈢殑姣斿鐮斿彂閮ㄩ棬锛屼篃涓嶆槸璺ㄧ晫锛屼絾濡傛灉鍋氶噾铻嶆垨浼佷笟绠$悊浜嗭紝灏辨槸璺ㄧ晫浜� - 杩欎釜闅惧害姣旇緝澶с€�
IP: 116.22.184.*   鍥炲 | 璧� 璧� +1 [1]鏇炬澃   2017-7-28 09:51
閮藉睘浜庡悓涓€涓鍩� - 鍒嗗瓙鐢熺墿瀛﹀惂锛�
濡傛灉妞嶇墿瀛﹀鍋氫复搴婂尰鐢熶簡锛屾墠鏄法鐣岋紙涓嶅悓琛屼笟锛夈€�
鍥炲  锛� 鎮ㄨ鐨勬槸銆備弗鏍兼潵璇达紝Ecker鐨勮法鐣屽箙搴︿篃璁告病鏈夋兂璞′腑鐨勯偅涔堝ぇ銆備笉杩囧仛妞嶇墿鐨勶紝鑳芥妸鐮旂┒棰嗗煙寤朵几鍒板姩鐗╁尰瀛︼紝杩欏凡缁忔槸姣旇緝灏戣鐨勪簡銆傛垜鍐欒繖绡囧崥鏂囩殑鐩殑锛屾槸鎻愰啋鑷繁锛屼笉瑕佹妸鐪煎厜鍙眬闄愬湪鑷繁鐨勭爺绌堕鍩燂紝鑰屽簲璇ヤ娇瑙嗛噹寮€闃斾竴鐐癸紝澶氫簡瑙d竴浜涘叾浠栨柟闈㈢殑鐭ヨ瘑銆備篃璁革紝浼氭湁鎰忔兂涓嶅埌鐨勬敹鑾枫€�
2017-7-28 12:281 妤硷紙鍥炲妤间富锛� 璧� 璧� +1 | 鍥炲

1/1 | 鎬昏:8 | 棣栭〉 | 涓婁竴椤� | 涓嬩竴椤� | 鏈〉 | 璺宠浆

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2025-3-16 16:36

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007-2025 中国科学报社

返回顶部