ShenHuiChuan的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/ShenHuiChuan

博文

沈惠川译:量子力学各种诠释的物理学特征

已有 4148 次阅读 2011-12-19 08:29 |个人分类:量子力学|系统分类:科研笔记| 量子力学, 诠释, 沈惠川

沈惠川译:量子力学各种诠释的物理学特征

(译自http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretation_of_quantum_mechanics/

The most common interpretations are summarized here (however, the assignment of values in the table is not without controversy, for the precise meanings of some of the concepts involved are unclear and, in fact, the subject of the very controversy itself):

No experimental evidence exists that would distinguish between the interpretations listed. To that extent, the physical theory stands, and is consistent with, itself and with reality; troubles come only when one attempts to "interpret" it. Nevertheless, there is active research in attempting to come up with experimental tests which would allow differences between the interpretations to be experimentally tested.

量子力学诠释

是否决定论的?

波函数是否是实在的?

是否一致性历史?

是否有隐变量?

波函数是否编缩?

测量有何作用?

Copenhagen 诠释
(
波函数并非实在的)

NA

NA

系综诠释
(
波函数并非实在的)

未知

毫无

Copenhagen诠释
(
波函数是实在的)
测量编缩理论

毫无

一致历史诠释
(
退相干近似)

未知1

未知1

视诠释²

量子逻辑诠释

未知

未知

³

视诠释²

大千世界诠释
(
退相干近似)

毫无

随机力学

毫无

智者千虑诠释

视诠释4

Bohm-de Broglie 量子势诠释
("
波导" 引领)

5

6

毫无

和谐诠释

7

毫无

Copenhagen诠释
(
波函数是实在的)
PAP

有因果

相关量子力学

未知8

9

毫无

不完全测量

10

10

视诠释²

1 If wavefunction is real then this becomes the many-worlds interpretation. If wavefunction less than real, but more than just information, then Zurek calls this the "existential interpretation".
2 Quantum mechanics is regarded as a way of predicting observations, or a theory of measurement..
3 But quantum logic is more limited in applicability than Coherent Histories.
4 Observers separate the universal wavefunction into orthogonal sets of experiences.
5 Both particle
AND
guiding wavefunction are real.
6 Unique particle history, but multiple wave histories.
7 In
the TI the collapse of the state vector is interpreted as the completion of the transaction between emitter and absorber.
8 Comparing histories between systems in this interpretation has no well-defined meaning.
9 Any physical interaction is treated as a collapse event relative to the systems involved, not just macroscopic or conscious observers.
10 The nature and collapse of the wavefunction are derived, not axiomatic.

Each interpretation has many variants. It is difficult to get a precise definition of the Copenhagen interpretation. In the table above, two variants are shown: one that regards the waveform as being a tool for calculating probabilities only, and the other regards the waveform as an "element of reality".

沈惠川按:本网页是吴震家博士向我推荐的。吴震家博士是我在上海市位育中学(曾名“上海市第五十一中学”)就读时最为知己的同学;我们一同做题,一同下棋;他现在定居于澳大利亚。


https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-605880-519826.html

上一篇:沈惠川:著名物理学家对Einstein的评价
下一篇:沈惠川: // 我的世界线:相对论之反击马青平
收藏 IP: 221.194.180.*| 热度|

3 刘全慧 肖重发 XY

该博文允许实名用户评论 评论 (1 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-12-24 20:43

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部