|
下面是我们组投稿时用来检查可视化文章专业性和写作的checklists:
可视化文章专业性的checklist:
1. 看看你的设计是否违反下面的原则:
- Eduard Tufte's's “How not to lie" rules
- 关于颜色使用的rules
- 关于visual encoding的effectiveness and expressiveness principles
- Tamara教科书里面总结出来的几个rules. 尤其是这三个rules: No 3D, Visualization Mantra (“overview first, zoom and filter, details on demand”), eyes beat memory
- UI和交互设计的3个rules: 优先级, 一致性, 隐喻
- 平面设计的CRAP原则:Contrast, Repetition, Alignment, Proximity
2. 画出Task, Design, Case studies的connection graph, 保证设计没有多余也没有缺失,每个设计都被case studies使用了。
3. 所有的design都讨论过alternative designs。整个系统或是design的scalability和generalization都讨论到了。
4. 完整的evaluation: case studies, comparison with baseline system(s), expert interview, user study (optional)
5. 文章提前三天做好,按照下面的proofreading checklist 过了一遍,而且送出去做language review。
Proofreading Checklist:
Grammar
· Articles
· Subject-Verb agreement
· Tense (Past tense is used in related work and conclusions)
· Run-on sentences (sentence 1, sentence 2)
· Fragment Sentences
Consistency
· bulleted list, table title, or figure caption inconsistently capitalized
· bulleted list, table title, or figure caption inconsistently punctuated
· heads inconsistently capitalized
· spelled the same name exactly the same way throughout your paper
Check figures and tables
· Check figure captions and table titles for consistency of spelling, style, and punctuation
· Check that figures and tables are positioned close to the text that discusses them
· Check that the figures and tables are in order (e.g., Fig 7 appearing before Fig. 6 not acceptable)
Aesthetic issues
· Check that line/page breaks occur at sensible locations (no page starts from a line with a single word)
Check the references
· Completeness (No missing page numbers, conference name, journal issue, and year)
· Consistency (Made sure that a journal title, no matter how often it occurs, is always spelled the same way?)
High-level issues
· Normalization
· Parallel structure
· Cohesion
o Do your sentences "hang together?”
o Does the sentence/paragraph begin with information familiar and end with interesting information the reader would not anticipate?
o Will your reader be able to identify quickly the "topic" of each paragraph?
Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )
GMT+8, 2024-9-1 16:18
Powered by ScienceNet.cn
Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社