lovellhe的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/lovellhe

博文

"乌合之众" 与 "异类:成功的故事" 的比较 __ 答案来自 ChatGPT

已有 986 次阅读 2023-5-19 10:07 |个人分类:杂感|系统分类:科研笔记

来自与ChatGPT答案:

 

Can you tell the connection and difference between the two books " Psychologie des foules" and " Outlier: the story of success"?


Version 1:

Psychologie des foules (The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind) by Gustave Le Bon is a groundbreaking study of how people tend to behave in crowds, and the social and psychological forces that drive their collective behaviour. Outlier: The Story of Success by Malcolm Gladwell explores the life stories of highly successful people who have achieved success outside the bounds of ordinary expectations. While Psychologie des foules focuses on the psychology of groups, Outlier: The Story of Success examines the unique characteristics of exceptionally successful individuals. Both books focus on patterns among people and their behaviours, but they differ in the context in which they are studied.

 

Version 2:

Psychologie des foules (translated to English: The Psychology of Crowds) was written by French psychologist Gustave Le Bon and was first published in 1895. It focuses on the study of group dynamics and collective behaviors, and how individuals behave in a collective context.

 

Outlier: The Story of Success was written by Malcolm Gladwell and is a compilation of his essays first published in 2008. The book addresses how and why some people are successful in unexpected ways, and how influential individual traits and other factors can be in determining success. The book connects individual success with broader social and cultural influences. While Psychologie des foules focuses specifically on group dynamics, Outlier explores the individual's role within a collective context. The books also contrast in that Psychologie des foules is based on largely historical research and case studies, while Outlier is an exploration of influential figures both past and present.

 

What are the main points in the Psychologie des foules (translated to English: The Psychology of Crowds)?

 

1. The theory of suggestion: Crowds are more likely to believe and act on suggestion than a single individual.

2. The theory of emotion: Crowds share an emotional state that can amplify certain feelings and lead to collective passions and behavior.

3. The theory of imitation: Individuals in a crowd can imitate the actions of others due to the anonymity of the situation.

4. The theory of contagion: Certain physiological changes are contagious in a crowd and can quickly spread, leading to a similar level of excitement among all individuals.

5. The theory of mentality: Clouded judgment and impulsive actions are common among the members of a crowd due to the collective influence.

6. The theory of organization: Crowds can be organized and structured in terms of their purpose and behavior.

7. The theory of the leader: The leader of a crowd provides a focus direction and is a common source of motivation.

 

What are the main points in the Outlier: the story of success?

 

1. Outliers are people who defy the norms, break conventions, and uncover success despite the odds.

2. Success is often the result of socioeconomic privilege, out-of-the-ordinary opportunities, and hard work.

3. To be successful, you must set ambitious goals, build strong and meaningful relationships, overcome adversity and develop discipline and skill.

4. The power of mentorship, the value of deliberate practice and the importance of cultural factors are all explored.

5. Lastly, Malcolm Gladwell argues that with enough effort, anyone can find success as an outlier.

 

 

 

翻译结果来自有道神经网络翻译(YNMT)· 通用场景

 

你能说出《犯心理学》和《局外人:成功的故事》这两本书之间的联系和区别吗?

 

版本1: 

古斯塔夫·勒邦(Gustave Le Bon)的《人群:大众心理研究》(Psychologie des foules)开创性地研究了人们在人群中的行为倾向,以及推动他们集体行为的社会和心理力量。马尔科姆·格拉德威尔的《异类:成功的故事》探讨了那些在普通预期之外取得成功的成功人士的生活故事。《犯罪心理学》关注的是群体心理,而《离群者:成功的故事》研究的是非常成功的个人的独特特征。这两本书都关注人们的行为模式,但它们在研究的背景上有所不同。

 

版本2: 

《人群心理学》(Psychologie des foules)是法国心理学家古斯塔夫·勒邦(Gustave Le Bon)1895年出版的著作。它侧重于研究群体动力学和集体行为,以及个人在集体背景下的行为。 

《异类:成功的故事》由马尔科姆·格拉德威尔(Malcolm Gladwell)撰写,是他2008年首次出版的论文的汇编。这本书讲述了一些人如何以及为什么会以意想不到的方式取得成功,以及个人特质和其他因素在决定成功方面的影响力。这本书将个人成功与更广泛的社会和文化影响联系起来。《心理学》特别关注群体动力学,而《局外人》则探讨个人在集体背景下的角色。这两本书的不同之处在于,《污垢心理学》主要基于历史研究和案例研究,而《局外人》则是对过去和现在有影响力的人物的探索。

 

 

 

《人群心理学》(Psychologie des foules)的主要观点是什么?

 

1. 暗示理论:群体比单个人更容易相信并根据暗示采取行动。 

2. 情绪理论:人群共享一种情绪状态,这种情绪状态可以放大某些感觉,并导致集体激情和行为。 

3.模仿理论:由于情境的匿名性,群体中的个体可以模仿他人的行为。 

4. 传染理论:某些生理变化在人群中具有传染性,可以迅速传播,导致所有个体的兴奋程度相似。 

5. 心理理论:由于集体影响,群体成员的判断模糊和冲动行为是普遍存在的。 

6. 组织理论:群体可以根据其目的和行为进行组织和结构。 

7. 领导者理论:群体的领导者提供了一个集中的方向,是一个共同的动力来源。 

 

 

《离群者:成功的故事》的要点是什么?

 

1. 异类是那些无视常规、打破常规、不顾困难成功的人。 

2. 成功往往是社会经济特权、难得的机会和努力工作的结果。 

3.要想成功,你必须设定雄心勃勃的目标,建立牢固而有意义的关系,克服逆境,培养自律和技能。 

4. 导师的力量,刻意练习的价值和文化因素的重要性都进行了探讨。 

5. 最后,马尔科姆·格拉德威尔(Malcolm Gladwell)认为,只要足够努力,任何人都可以像局外人一样找到成功。

 




https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-3367056-1388596.html

上一篇:未来交通:何去何从?The future of transportation: Where will we go?
下一篇:Nothing is Stronger Than a Human Being’s Longing for Freedom
收藏 IP: 101.224.159.*| 热度|

0

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-4-27 20:40

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部