lix分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/lix

博文

全球谴责声中特立独行的另类

已有 5059 次阅读 2010-10-8 04:47 |个人分类:怪哉虫儿|系统分类:观点评述| 赤脚医生, 危地马拉, 塔斯基吉, 卡特勒

在美国政府为卡特勒在危地马拉的人体实验道歉之后,全球掀起了谴责的风暴。很多美国人也在网上谴责自己的国家干出了德国集中营和日本731同样的事。只有一位特立独行,说:

This is different. This was done to citizens of another country, not even POWs, and with almost certainty done with a consent of that country's government at the time. USA can feel a lot of guilt about it, but we were not at war with that country, were not occupying that country at that time, and didn't enforce this crime with any kind of US government force. We have here something to be ashamed of, no question about it, but Guatemala should blame their own people first and foremost for what has happened.
Because it would not have happened in case their government, that is some Guatemalan people, would not have given a green light for that. I don't give a **** whether we bribed them, blackmailed them into this or whatever it is .. if their government would have said "No", none of these would have happened. So. as always .. the government of the country bears most of responsibility for whatever happens in the country. By becoming a government they signed up for that responsibility. I don't think USA should even apologize for that.. Should we call this regretful? Fine. But it should be understood that it happened because of executive decision of someone who is not under American jurisdiction. Period.

原贴似已删除,但被有心人保留在http://tieba.baidu.com/f?kz=904346583

全球对美谴责声中,科学网似乎是一个宁静的港湾。反而与上引帖子类似为美辩护的观点充斥在对我三博文天不佑老肖,塔斯基吉实验起新波澜几个评论和老邪的答复卡特勒人体实验对伦理的四种侵犯的反对声中。这是很奇怪的事。



https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-2984-370751.html

上一篇:卡特勒人体实验对伦理的四种侵犯
下一篇:科研要向游戏学习

15 刘华杰 王铮 朱志敏 王德华 陈安 任国鹏 熊李虎 赵宇 许培扬 丛远新 刘庆丰 马磊 zy88093139 侯振宇 WC101

发表评论 评论 (7 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2022-6-29 21:22

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部