随想图情分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/周春雷 博以知不足,在灌水中聆听生命的嬉戏

博文

请教一下ISSI 2009国际会议论文问题

已有 9393 次阅读 2009-3-10 14:32 |个人分类:学术评价|系统分类:科研笔记| 2009, ISSI, 国际会议论文

请教一下ISSI 2009国际会议论文问题

我们投了一篇文章,被接受了。https://www.softconf.com/s08/issi2009/

这个会好像是在巴西开的,我们是穷学生,该如何处理这个事情呢?这个会议的级别怎么样,不现场参加会议是否文章就不会被收录呢?大家给点建议。

> On behalf of the ISSI 2009 Program Committee, I am delighted
> to inform you that you full paper submission (Number 30) has been accepted
> to appear at the conference:
>
> Literature-based Multidiscipline Knowledge Discovery:
> A New Application of Bibliometrics
>
> The Program Committee worked very hard to thoroughly review
> all the submitted papers. Please repay their efforts, by
> following their suggestions given below when you revise your paper.


REVIEWER #1

> Significance of the problem: 5
> Originality: 3
> Quality of methodology or treatment: 4
> Validity of claims & interpretation: 3
> Adequacy of citations; recognition of previous work: 3
> Quality of writing (language, style & organization): 3
> Paper length: Yes
> Overall assessment: 3
> Reviewer's confidence: 4
> Recommendation: ACCEPT

REVIEWER #2

> Significance of the problem: 4
> Originality: 4
> Quality of methodology or treatment: 5
> Validity of claims & interpretation: 4
> Adequacy of citations; recognition of previous work: 5
> Quality of writing (language, style & organization): 5
> Paper length: Yes
> Overall assessment: 4
> Reviewer's confidence: 5
> Recommendation: ACCEPT

REVIEWER #3
> Significance of the problem: 2
> Originality: 2
> Quality of methodology or treatment: 3
> Validity of claims & interpretation: 3
> Adequacy of citations; recognition of previous work: 3
> Quality of writing (language, style & organization): 2
> Paper length: Yes
> Overall assessment: 3
> Reviewer's confidence: 4
> Recommendation: --> POSTER



https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-60286-219454.html

上一篇:关于“博主好友”的一点说明
下一篇:禁止匿名评论完全是因噎废食
收藏 IP: .*| 热度|

0

发表评论 评论 (2 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-11-23 11:10

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部