博文
由“荧光粉微波合成”文献引用看（国人）治学之不严谨
|||
看今天的一篇精选博文，基金委的评审意见，无意中注意到里面提到了核心关键词，荧光粉的微波合成，勾起了一段很久以前的记忆（a story from long ago）.
于是，去了知网空间 http://www.cnki.com.cn/，搜索了一番相关学术论文的发表和引用情况。
使用主题词，微波+荧光体，得到记录 50条，
使用主题词，微波+荧光粉，得到记录 124条，
二者合在一起是174条，并且一定会有重叠，因为不管荧光体还是荧光粉，英文只有一个名字，phosphor，于是，使用主题词，微波+ phosphor ，得到记录 151条，这是一个比较靠谱的数据。
再看最早的一篇正式论文是1995年发表在某个学报上的，可是引用率只有区区39次，39次对151条记录，可怜吗？真可怜！
这篇1995年发表的中文论文，起码是国内第一篇文献，当然具有很强的原创性，最起码也是国内的第一份工作，该篇后面的这么多篇论文，证明了具有很强的开创性。
其实，这一篇也是世界领域的原创性和开创性工作。去web of science网页，使用 microwave AND phosphor 搜索得到249 篇论文, 按年代倒排第237篇，更早的12篇工作用到了这两个主题词，但是都是其他领域的工作，比如phosphor 在微波波段的物理性质，或者使用微波干燥去处水分等，详细附在下面。
可以这些后来的论文竟然引用都没有？这能算治学严谨吗？
顺便思考一些问题，开创和原创性的工作都需要发表在顶级杂志吗？开创和原创性的工作都能有很好的引用吗？
243.Title: PHOTO-LUMINESCENT THERMOMETRY BASED ON EUROPIUM-ACTIVATED CALCIUM SULFIDE
Author(s): SAMULSKI, TV; CHOPPING, PT; HAAS, B
Source: PHYSICS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume: 27 Issue: 1 Pages: 107-114
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-99360-609899.html
上一篇：“屠刀上的医院”：深圳出现伤害医护事件
下一篇：英国奥运封神榜配额已出，奖牌贬值
于是，去了知网空间 http://www.cnki.com.cn/，搜索了一番相关学术论文的发表和引用情况。
使用主题词，微波+荧光体，得到记录 50条，
使用主题词，微波+荧光粉，得到记录 124条，
二者合在一起是174条，并且一定会有重叠，因为不管荧光体还是荧光粉，英文只有一个名字，phosphor，于是，使用主题词，微波+ phosphor ，得到记录 151条，这是一个比较靠谱的数据。
再看最早的一篇正式论文是1995年发表在某个学报上的，可是引用率只有区区39次，39次对151条记录，可怜吗？真可怜！
这篇1995年发表的中文论文，起码是国内第一篇文献，当然具有很强的原创性，最起码也是国内的第一份工作，该篇后面的这么多篇论文，证明了具有很强的开创性。
其实，这一篇也是世界领域的原创性和开创性工作。去web of science网页，使用 microwave AND phosphor 搜索得到249 篇论文, 按年代倒排第237篇，更早的12篇工作用到了这两个主题词，但是都是其他领域的工作，比如phosphor 在微波波段的物理性质，或者使用微波干燥去处水分等，详细附在下面。
可以这些后来的论文竟然引用都没有？这能算治学严谨吗？
顺便思考一些问题，开创和原创性的工作都需要发表在顶级杂志吗？开创和原创性的工作都能有很好的引用吗？
附录：
238. Title: ACCELERATED MICROWAVE SYNTHESIS OF MAGNESIUM SULFIDE WITH THE PRO-HEATING MEDIUM OF GRAPHITE
Author(s): XU, Y; XIAO, XY
Source: JOURNAL OF MATERIALS RESEARCH Volume: 10 Issue: 2 Pages: 334-338
238. Title: ACCELERATED MICROWAVE SYNTHESIS OF MAGNESIUM SULFIDE WITH THE PRO-HEATING MEDIUM OF GRAPHITE
Author(s): XU, Y; XIAO, XY
Source: JOURNAL OF MATERIALS RESEARCH Volume: 10 Issue: 2 Pages: 334-338
DOI: 10.1557/JMR.1995.0334 Published: FEB 1995
Times Cited: 13 (from All Databases)
239. Title: MULTIPLE-QUANTUM EPR TRANSITIONS OF MNII IN CASMNII PHOSPHOR
Author(s): GOURIER, D; SIMONS, D; VIVIEN, D; et al.
Source: PHYSICA STATUS SOLIDI B-BASIC RESEARCH Volume: 180 Issue: 1 Pages: 223-235
Author(s): GOURIER, D; SIMONS, D; VIVIEN, D; et al.
Source: PHYSICA STATUS SOLIDI B-BASIC RESEARCH Volume: 180 Issue: 1 Pages: 223-235
DOI: 10.1002/pssb.2221800121 Published: NOV 1993
Times Cited: 5 (from All Databases)
240. Title: SYSTEM FOR VELOCITY RATIO MEASUREMENTS OF AN AXIS-ROTATING ELECTRON-BEAM
Author(s): BOULAIS, KA; CHOE, JY; NAMKUNG, W; et al.
Source: REVIEW OF SCIENTIFIC INSTRUMENTS Volume: 64 Issue: 4 Pages: 958-961
Author(s): BOULAIS, KA; CHOE, JY; NAMKUNG, W; et al.
Source: REVIEW OF SCIENTIFIC INSTRUMENTS Volume: 64 Issue: 4 Pages: 958-961
DOI: 10.1063/1.1144149 Published: APR 1993
Times Cited: 0 (from All Databases)
241.Title: MEASUREMENT OF THE SURFACE OF TEXTILES DURING MICROWAVE DRYING USING A THERMOGRAPHIC PHOSPHOR
Author(s): DEVER, M; BUGOS, A; DYER, F; et al.
Source: JOURNAL OF MICROWAVE POWER AND ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY Volume: 25 Issue: 4 Pages: 230-235
Author(s): DEVER, M; BUGOS, A; DYER, F; et al.
Source: JOURNAL OF MICROWAVE POWER AND ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY Volume: 25 Issue: 4 Pages: 230-235
Published: 1990
Times Cited: 0 (from All Databases)
242.Title: THERMO-LUMINESCENCE OF RARE-EARTH DOPED BASO4 PHOSPHORS AND ITS APPLICATIONS
Author(s): NAGPAL, JS; VARADHARAJAN, G
Source: INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED RADIATION AND ISOTOPES Volume: 33 Issue: 3 Pages: 175-182
Source: INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED RADIATION AND ISOTOPES Volume: 33 Issue: 3 Pages: 175-182
DOI:10.1016/0020-708X(82)90108-9 Published: 1982
Times Cited: 4 (from All Databases)
243.Title: PHOTO-LUMINESCENT THERMOMETRY BASED ON EUROPIUM-ACTIVATED CALCIUM SULFIDE
Author(s): SAMULSKI, TV; CHOPPING, PT; HAAS, B
Source: PHYSICS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume: 27 Issue: 1 Pages: 107-114
DOI: 10.1088/0031-9155/27/1/011 Published: 1982
Times Cited: 13 (from All Databases)
244. Title: A PRELIMINARY-STUDY OF THERMOLUMINESCENT PHOSPHORS AS DOSIMETERS FOR MICROWAVE-RADIATION
Author(s): NAGPAL, JS; VARADHARAJAN, G; GANGADHARAN, P
Source: PHYSICS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume: 27 Issue: 1 Pages: 145-148
Author(s): NAGPAL, JS; VARADHARAJAN, G; GANGADHARAN, P
Source: PHYSICS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume: 27 Issue: 1 Pages: 145-148
DOI: 10.1088/0031-9155/27/1/015 Published: 1982T
imes Cited: 2 (from All Databases)
245.Title: THERMOLUMINESCENCE OF HIGH DIELECTRIC-CONSTANT MATERIALS
Author(s): ELLE, DR; VETTER, RJ; ZIEMER, PL
Source: HEALTH PHYSICS Volume: 29 Issue: 1 Pages: 220-223 Published: 1975
Author(s): ELLE, DR; VETTER, RJ; ZIEMER, PL
Source: HEALTH PHYSICS Volume: 29 Issue: 1 Pages: 220-223 Published: 1975
Times Cited: 1 (from All Databases)
246.Title: MICROWAVE PHOTOCONDUCTIVITY AND LUMINESCENCE OF ZNS AND CDS PHOSPHORS
Author(s): KRAMER, B; KALIKSTE.K; GELFMAN, S
Source: PHYSICAL REVIEW B Volume: 6 Issue: 2 Pages: 556-&
Author(s): KRAMER, B; KALIKSTE.K; GELFMAN, S
Source: PHYSICAL REVIEW B Volume: 6 Issue: 2 Pages: 556-&
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.6.556 Published: 1972T
imes Cited: 15 (from All Databases)
247.Title: INVESTIGATION OF PHOTOCONDUCTIVITY IN ZNS AND CDS PHOSPHORS WITH MICROWAVE METHODS
Author(s): KALIKSTE.K; KRAMER, B; GELFMAN, S
Source: JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS Volume: 39 Issue: 9 Pages: 4252-&
Author(s): KALIKSTE.K; KRAMER, B; GELFMAN, S
Source: JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS Volume: 39 Issue: 9 Pages: 4252-&
DOI: 10.1063/1.1656956 Published: 1968
Times Cited: 13 (from All Databases)
248.Title: DOUBLE BEAM SPECTROPHOTOMETRY IN FAR ULTRAVIOLET .1. 1150 A TO 3600 A
Author(s): SCHMITT, RG; BREHM, RK
Source: APPLIED OPTICS Volume: 5 Issue: 7 Pages: 1111-&
Author(s): SCHMITT, RG; BREHM, RK
Source: APPLIED OPTICS Volume: 5 Issue: 7 Pages: 1111-&
DOI: 10.1364/AO.5.001111 Published: 1966T
imes Cited: 23 (from All Databases)
249.Title: PARAMAGNETIC RESONANCE IN PHOSPHORS AT MICROWAVE FREQUENCIES
Author(s): HERSHBERGER, WD; LEIFER, HN
Source: REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS Volume: 25 Issue: 1 Pages: 291-291
Author(s): HERSHBERGER, WD; LEIFER, HN
Source: REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS Volume: 25 Issue: 1 Pages: 291-291
DOI: 10.1103/RevModPhys.25.291 Published:1953
Times Cited: 1 (from All Databases)
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-99360-609899.html
上一篇：“屠刀上的医院”：深圳出现伤害医护事件
下一篇：英国奥运封神榜配额已出，奖牌贬值
