博文
《Cell》撤稿，“倒念”刘实
|||
首先说明，这篇博文的题目是“风马牛相集”的结果。
本来，《Cell》撤稿与刘实无关，因为所撤之稿非刘实所写。
但《Cell》撤稿却又与刘实相集，因为它是刘实“狂言”的“CNS生命科学论文至少三分之一是错的而应撤稿”之“刘论”的具体体现之一。
《Cell》的最新一篇撤稿是：
Cell, Volume 143, Issue 3, 485, 29 October 2010
doi:10.1016/j.cell.2010.10.011
Alvar Trucco, Imre Gaspar and Anne Ephrussi
(Cell 139, 983 998; November 25, 2009)
In this paper, we used cryoimmuno-electron microscopy and live-cell imaging to investigate the sequential assembly of oskar mRNA into an mRNP competent for transport from the Drosophila nurse cells to the oocyte posterior pole. We have recently identified instances in all of the figures where the cryoimmuno-EM data were inappropriately manipulated by the first author. The manipulations do not affect the live-cell imaging data. We are in the process of reanalyzing the raw experimental cryoimmuno-EM data but can already state that the published conclusions are not fully consistent with the raw data. We are therefore retracting the paper. We sincerely apologize for any inconvenience that this might have caused.
所以，现在“倒念”起刘实来，我还真被他的英明折服，更为他的勇敢感动。
下面是我从刘实的“求真”网站上找到的一篇刘实投给《Cell》而被拒稿、但后来发表在“高人”所编的真顶尖（锐）杂志的文章。按他的文章所指，《Cell》撤稿的力度还远远不够。而这篇文章所列的还是刘实2008年前的投稿。好像他后来还给《Cell》投过一些也被拒稿。但他的文章现在“倒念”起来还都是对的（在我看来）。
A Summary of Cell’s Rejections on Shi V. Liu’s Submissions
|
Title
|
Submitted
|
Rejected
|
Published*
|
|
Searching for the Deep Root and
Fundamental Mechanism of Biotic Aging
|
20050311
|
20050318
|
LB 5:89-91, 2005
|
|
"Cellular Senescence": What Does It Really Mean?
|
20051004
|
20051016
|
LB 5:308-310, 2005
|
|
Piggyback on a Nobel Prize or Show Its True Spirit
|
20060109
|
20060203
|
LB 6:12-15, 2006
|
|
Stop Playing the Cell Differentiation Tune for Caulobacter
|
20060405
|
20060407
|
LB 6: 31-32, 2006
|
|
Cell Division versus Cell Reproduction
|
20060816
|
20060817
|
LB 6:62-64, 2006
|
|
Revisit Semi-Conservative DNA Replication and Immortal DNA Strand Hypothesis
|
20060824
|
20060825
|
LB 6:54-61, 2006
|
|
Why we keep losing excellence in young scientists?
|
20060820
|
20060825
|
LB 6:65-66, 2006
|
|
Are Stem Cells Really Immortal Cells?
|
20060909
|
20061002
|
LB 6:71-75, 2006
|
|
Sorry, I Am Not Your Grandfather
|
20061117
|
20061118
|
Pioneer 1: 5-7, 2006
|
|
Stem Cells’ Self-Renewal or Cell Biologists’ Self-Cheating?
|
20061219
|
20061223
|
LB 6:106-109, 2006
|
|
What Is a Stem Cell?
|
20070129
|
20070130
|
LB 7:12-17, 2007
|
|
Liu’s Message Blocked by “Top” Journals
|
20070314
|
20070315
|
Sci. Ethics 2: 5-6, 2007
|
|
Respecting Published Answers for Important Questions on Epigenetics
|
20070320
|
20070411
|
Top Watch 2: 19-20,2007
|
|
No Real Evidence for Round Trip in Spermatogenesis
|
20070423
|
No Reply!
|
LB 7:26-28, 2007
|
|
Immortal Strand Does Not Exist but
Nonrandom Strand Segregation Should Be Universal
|
20070722
|
20070803
|
LB 7:26-28, 2007
|
|
An alternative view on nonrandom DNA segregation and cell life
|
20080810
|
No Reply
|
Unpublished
|
|
Induction of pluripotency: where is the evidence?
|
20081125
|
No Reply
|
Top Watch 2:94, 2007
|
|
iPS cells are man-made cancer cells
|
20080121
|
No Reply
|
LB 8: 16-18, 2008
|
|
Evidence for Selection of Pre-existing Stem Cells Rather than Induction of iPS Cells
|
20080501
|
No Reply
|
LB 8: 52-54, 2008
|
*LB = Logical Biology. This and other journals can be read at http://im1.biz
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-84542-380873.html
上一篇：Nature这样改错也是好的!
下一篇：刘实本性难改：“双规”还管“国事”、修“奶车”
