1-Accept
含义:直接接收
评论:不可能的事(Never happens),没人能享受到(Which
almost nobody gets)
2-accept after minor revision
含义:小改,修回后不需要再送给reviewer审阅("Just make
some minor changes.")
评论:不多见(Once every blue moon)
3-reconsideration after major revision
含义:大改,修回后要再送给上次的审reviewer审阅
评价:很好的消息(Very good news),他们仍对你的文章感兴趣
("They're still interested in you!")
4-reject and resubmit
含义:论文现在状态不能接受,但可以修改后重新再投,要重新经过审稿
流程,一般是送交与上一次不同的reviewer审阅
评论:坏消息,但可以通过增加实验来解决(Bad news but you can
handle it with more experiments),尽管不是好消息,但是他们仍对你
的文章感兴趣(Though not as good as revise, "they still want the
paper!")
5-reject
含义:拒稿
评论:投该杂志没希望了(F-Off Rejection),但是并不是说文章没希望
了,只是说这篇文章不适合该杂志("They're not saying the article is
hopeless," says Neal-Barnett, "they're just saying that it may not be
right for that journal.")
注意:“reject and resubmit”含义与“reject”的细微差别:
如果是“reject and resubmit”会让你resubmit时注明上次的稿件编号,
而“reject”则作为一篇新文章resubmit(resubmit the paper as a new
paper)