宁愿发表错误文章，也不发表垃圾文章

是鼓励创新。这种冒着错误的危险发表了错误文章比发表垃圾文章更有意义，是可以接受的。

但是，明明知道文章是错误的，仍然坚持发表是恶劣的学术不端。

学术世界并不太大，有时候你能猜到审稿人是谁：

科学网—[转载]同行评审就是你的同行有能力阻止世界了解你的工作 (科技英文听力资料，英汉对照） - 刘跃的博文 (sciencenet.cn)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5sRYsMjiAQ

The Problem With Peer Review - Eric Weinstein

https://blog.sciencenet.cn/video.php?mod=vinfo&pid=3500

有的审稿人在坚决拒了我们的稿件后，其团队继续发表坚持现行错误的微波吸收理论的文章。表明他的课题组已经知晓了反对观点，但是仍然坚持现行微波吸收理论。

有三种解释：

1）审稿人的团队已经知道并且跟踪了反方的观点，知道自己的理论是错的。但是为了考核、为了学生毕业、或者为了向以前的编辑表明自己坚定的立场，不得已而坚持错误理论。凭借自己的权威为错误理论殉道。

2）你不是假装以为错误的理论是”正确“，你是内心真的认为错误的理论是”正确的“。但是这样的话你应该不怕争论。在你的后续文章中你不应该回避错误的反对观点，你需要在你的文章中引用并批判错误的观点，以说明你为什么坚持现行理论。（很多主流学者坚持对付“民科”的最好方法就是置之不理，但这不是科学的态度）

3）在正确和错误的理论之间，你分别不出谁是谁非。所以尽管你的拒稿意见很坚决，但是你还是吃不准，不敢往文章里写。然而，要知道，面对两种理论，只要有大学本科《普通物理》和初中数学的水平，就能辨别出现行微波吸收理论和反对理论谁对谁错。如果你辨别不出来，那么无论你是什么级别的学术权威，多么名噪一时，无论你实验室的仪器多么先进、你在顶级刊物发了多少文章、你拿到了多少项目经费，你的整个课题组都毫无疑问是混混。

=========================

我们名不见经传、几乎没有在顶刊发表文章、一辈子没有拿到一项国家自然科学基金的面上项目、我们的仪器很简陋，但是我们敢于在我们的文章中旗帜鲜明地亮出自己的观点，我们不畏惧权威刊物和学术权威，我们敢于引用他们的文章。

https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-3589443-1421765.html

现行微波吸收理论混淆了膜和材料的区别（公开的学术擂台，接受挑战）

科学网—最新顶刊现行微波吸收理论文章和低级别刊物反对文章之间的比较（让历史做最终的裁决） - 刘跃的博文 (sciencenet.cn)

The Electron Migration Polarization Boosting Electromagnetic Wave Absorption Based on Ce Atoms Modulated yolk@shell FexN@NGC, Adv. Mater. 2024, 2314233, 

First published: 21 February 2024

Received: December 27, 2023

Revised: February 19, 2024

https://doi.org/10.1002/adma.202314233

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adma.202314233

The Electron Migration Polarization Boosting Electromagnetic Wave Absorption Based on

 Ce Atoms Modulated yolk@shell FexN@NGC - Ma - Advanced Materials - Wiley Online Library

科学网—分析一篇微波吸收科普文章中的代表性错误 - 刘跃的博文 (sciencenet.cn):

顶刊发表的错误文章

[1] J. Cheng, H. Zhang, M. Ning, H. Raza, D. Zhang, G. Zheng, Q. Zheng, R. Che, Emerging Materials and Designs for Low‐ and Multi‐Band Electromagnetic Wave Absorbers: The Search for Dielectric and Magnetic Synergy?, Advanced Functional Materials, 32 (2022) 2200123.

[2] Y. Akinay, U. Gunes, B. Çolak, T. Cetin, Recent progress of electromagnetic wave absorbers: A systematic review and bibliometric approach, ChemPhysMater, 2 (2023) 197-206.

[3] Z. Zhao, Y. Qing, L. Kong, H. Xu, X. Fan, J. Yun, L. Zhang, H. Wu, Advancements in Microwave Absorption Motivated by Interdisciplinary Research, Advanced Materials, 36 (2023) 2304182

[4] Q. An, D. Li, W. Liao, T. Liu, D. Joralmon, X. Li, J. Zhao, A Novel Ultra‐Wideband Electromagnetic‐Wave‐Absorbing Metastructure Inspired by Bionic Gyroid Structures, Advanced Materials, 35 (2023) 2300659.

[5] G. Chen, H. Liang, J. Yun, L. Zhang, H. Wu, J. Wang, Ultrasonic Field Induces Better Crystallinity And Abundant Defects at Grain Boundaries to Develop Cus Electromagnetic Wave Absorber, Advanced Materials, 35 (2023) 2305586.

[6] J. Ma, J. Choi, S. Park, I. Kong, D. Kim, C. Lee, Y. Youn, M. Hwang, S. Oh, W. Hong, W. Kim, Liquid Crystals for Advanced Smart Devices with Microwave and Millimeter‐Wave Applications: Recent Progress for Next‐Generation Communications, Advanced Materials, (2023).

[7] J. Yan, Q. Zheng, S.P. Wang, Y.Z. Tian, W.Q. Gong, F. Gao, J.J. Qiu, L. Li, S.H. Yang, M.S. Cao, Multifunctional Organic–Inorganic Hybrid Perovskite Microcrystalline Engineering and Electromagnetic Response Switching Multi‐Band Devices, Advanced Materials, 35 (2023) 2300015.

[8] B. Zhao, Z. Yan, Y. Du, L. Rao, G. Chen, Y. Wu, L. Yang, J. Zhang, L. Wu, D.W. Zhang, R. Che, High‐Entropy Enhanced Microwave Attenuation in Titanate Perovskites, Advanced Materials, 35 (2023) 2210243.

[9] I. Huynen, N. Quiévy, C. Bailly, P. Bollen, C. Detrembleur, S. Eggermont, I. Molenberg, J.M. Thomassin, L. Urbanczyk, T. Pardoen, Multifunctional hybrids for electromagnetic absorption, Acta Materialia, 59 (2011) 3255-3266.

[10] W. Yang, Y. Zhang, G. Qiao, Y. Lai, S. Liu, C. Wang, J. Han, H. Du, Y. Zhang, Y. Yang, Y. Hou, J. Yang, Tunable magnetic and microwave absorption properties of Sm1.5Y0.5Fe17-xSix and their composites, Acta Materialia, 145 (2018) 331-336.

[11] R.H. Fan, B. Xiong, R.W. Peng, M. Wang, Constructing Metastructures with Broadband Electromagnetic Functionality, Adv Mater, 32 (2020) 1904646.

[12] L. Liang, W. Gu, Y. Wu, B. Zhang, G. Wang, Y. Yang, G. Ji, Heterointerface Engineering in Electromagnetic Absorbers: New Insights and Opportunities, Adv Mater, 34 (2022) 2106195.

[13] Q. Liu, Q. Cao, H. Bi, C. Liang, K. Yuan, W. She, Y. Yang, R. Che, CoNi@SiO2 @TiO2 and CoNi@Air@TiO2 Microspheres with Strong Wideband Microwave Absorption, Adv Mater, 28 (2016) 486-490.

[14] H. Sun, R. Che, X. You, Y. Jiang, Z. Yang, J. Deng, L. Qiu, H. Peng, Cross-stacking aligned carbon-nanotube films to tune microwave absorption frequencies and increase absorption intensities, Adv Mater, 26 (2014) 8120–8125.

[15] Z. Wu, H.W. Cheng, C. Jin, B. Yang, C. Xu, K. Pei, H. Zhang, Z. Yang, R. Che, Dimensional Design and Core-Shell Engineering of Nanomaterials for Electromagnetic Wave Absorption, Adv Mater, 34 (2022) 2107538.

[16] C.M. Watts, X. Liu, W.J. Padilla, Metamaterial electromagnetic wave absorbers, Advanced  Materials, 24 (2012) OP98-OP120.

[17] M.S. Cao, X.X. Wang, M. Zhang, J.C. Shu, W.Q. Cao, H.J. Yang, X.Y. Fang, J. Yuan, Electromagnetic Response and Energy Conversion for Functions and Devices in Low‐Dimensional Materials, Advanced Functional Materials, 29 (2019) 1807398.

[18] P. Liu, Y. Wang, G. Zhang, Y. Huang, R. Zhang, X. Liu, X. Zhang, R. Che, Hierarchical Engineering of Double‐Shelled Nanotubes toward Hetero‐Interfaces Induced Polarization and Microscale Magnetic Interaction, Advanced Functional Materials, 32 (2022) 2202588.

[19] P. Liu, G. Zhang, H. Xu, S. Cheng, Y. Huang, B. Ouyang, Y. Qian, R. Zhang, R. Che, Synergistic Dielectric–Magnetic Enhancement via Phase‐Evolution Engineering and Dynamic Magnetic Resonance, Advanced Functional Materials, 33 (2023) 2211298.

[20] J.C. Shu, M.S. Cao, M. Zhang, X.X. Wang, W.Q. Cao, X.Y. Fang, M.Q. Cao, Molecular Patching Engineering to Drive Energy Conversion as Efficient and Environment‐Friendly Cell toward Wireless Power Transmission, Advanced Functional Materials, 30 (2020) 1908299.

[21] Y. Xia, W. Gao, C. Gao, A Review on Graphene‐Based Electromagnetic Functional Materials: Electromagnetic Wave Shielding and Absorption, Advanced Functional Materials, 32 (2022) 2204591.

[22] F. Ye, Q. Song, Z. Zhang, W. Li, S. Zhang, X. Yin, Y. Zhou, H. Tao, Y. Liu, L. Cheng, L. Zhang, H. Li, Direct Growth of Edge-Rich Graphene with Tunable Dielectric Properties in Porous Si3N4 Ceramic for Broadband High-Performance Microwave Absorption, Advanced Functional Materials, 28 (2018) 1707205.

====================

科学网—大咖们写的综述有多大的学术价值？ - 刘跃的博文 (sciencenet.cn)

”看一看一天全世界要发表多少篇论文？如果每一篇文章都有创新，仅仅用最粗浅的形而上学逻辑分析一下，世界将如何飞速地发展。

有那么多顶刊，每天在顶刊上就发表大量“重大创新”结果！

有多少“创新”是编造出来的？

那么多的综述文章，几乎没有一篇综述文章发现了一丁点的“伪创新”。如果这么大量的伪创新你都发现不了，还要综述文章有何用？难道综述只是用来赞美的吗？“

微波吸收领域的一些综述文章：

[1] J. Cheng, H. Zhang, M. Ning, H. Raza, D. Zhang, G. Zheng, Q. Zheng, R. Che, Emerging Materials and Designs for Low‐ and Multi‐Band Electromagnetic Wave Absorbers: The Search for Dielectric and Magnetic Synergy?, Advanced Functional Materials, 32 (2022) 2200123. perspective

[2] Y. Akinay, U. Gunes, B. Çolak, T. Cetin, Recent progress of electromagnetic wave absorbers: A systematic review and bibliometric approach, ChemPhysMater, 2 (2023) 197-206.

[3] A.A. Abu Sanad, M.N. Mahmud, M.F. Ain, M.A.B. Ahmad, N.Z.B. Yahaya, Z. Mohamad Ariff, Theory, Modeling, Measurement, and Testing of Electromagnetic Absorbers: A Review, physica status solidi (a), (2023) 2300828.

[4] Y. Xia, W. Gao, C. Gao, A Review on Graphene‐Based Electromagnetic Functional Materials: Electromagnetic Wave Shielding and Absorption, Advanced Functional Materials, 32 (2022) 2204591.

[5] B. Li, F. Wang, K. Wang, J. Qiao, D. Xu, Y. Yang, X. Zhang, L. Lyu, W. Liu, J. Liu, Metal sulfides based composites as promising efficient microwave absorption materials: A review, Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 104 (2022) 244-268.

[6] M.F. Elmahaishi, R.a.S. Azis, I. Ismail, F.D. Muhammad, A review on electromagnetic microwave absorption properties: their materials and performance, Journal of Materials Research and Technology, 20 (2022) 2188-2220.

[7] G. Devi, R. Priya, B.R. Tapas Bapu, R. Thandaiah Prabu, P.J. Sathish Kumar, N. Anusha, Role of carbonaceous fillers in electromagnetic interference shielding behavior of polymeric composites: A review, Polymer Composites, 43 (2022) 7701-7723.

[8] H. Zhao, F. Wang, L. Cui, X. Xu, X. Han, Y. Du, Composition Optimization and Microstructure Design in MOFs-Derived Magnetic Carbon-Based Microwave Absorbers: A Review, Nano-micro Lett, 13 (2021) 208.

[9] Z. Zhang, Z. Cai, Z. Wang, Y. Peng, L. Xia, S. Ma, Z. Yin, Y. Huang, A Review on Metal-Organic Framework-Derived Porous Carbon-Based Novel Microwave Absorption Materials, Nano-micro Lett, 13 (2021) 56.

[10] P. Wang, D. Liu, L. Cui, B. Hu, X. Han, Y. Du, A review of recent advancements in Ni-related materials used for microwave absorption, Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, 54 (2021) 473003.

[11] S.S. Pattanayak, S.H. Laskar, S. Sahoo, Progress on agricultural residue-based microwave absorber: a review and prospects, Journal of Materials Science, 56 (2021) 4097-4119.

[12] E. Mikinka, M. Siwak, Recent advances in electromagnetic interference shielding properties of carbon-fibre-reinforced polymer composites—a topical review, Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics, 32 (2021) 24585-24643.

[13] J. Ma, J. Choi, S. Park, I. Kong, D. Kim, C. Lee, Y. Youn, M. Hwang, S. Oh, W. Hong, W. Kim, Liquid Crystals for Advanced Smart Devices with Microwave and Millimeter‐Wave Applications: Recent Progress for Next‐Generation Communications, Advanced Materials, (2023).

[14] K. Chand, X. Zhang, Y. Chen, Recent progress in MXene and graphene based nanocomposites for microwave absorption and electromagnetic interference shielding, Arabian Journal of Chemistry, 15 (2022) 104143.

[15] F. Peng, M. Dai, Z. Wang, Y. Guo, Z. Zhou, Progress in graphene-based magnetic hybrids towards highly efficiency for microwave absorption, Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 106 (2022) 147-161.

[16] M. Green, X. Chen, Recent progress of nanomaterials for microwave absorption, Journal of Materiomics, 5 (2019) 503-541.

[17] L. Huang, C. Chen, Z. Li, Y. Zhang, H. Zhang, J. Lu, S. Ruan, Y.J. Zeng, Challenges and future perspectives on microwave absorption based on two-dimensional materials and structures, Nanotechnology, 31 (2020) 162001.

[18] H. Bai, P. Yin, X. Lu, L. Zhang, W. Wu, X. Feng, J. Wang, J. Dai, Recent advances of magnetism-based microwave absorbing composites: an insight from perspective of typical morphologies, Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics, 32 (2021) 25577-25602.

===================

补充阅读：

科学网—华科瞿金平院士团队：用于多场景快速储能和电磁屏蔽的自组装MXene基相变复合材料 - 纳微快报的博文 (sciencenet.cn)

科学网—黄小萧/车仁超等：微量铁注入对石墨烯介电与吸波性能的调控机制 - 纳微快报的博文 (sciencenet.cn)