*****根据我在2016年铜陵中国图书馆学会年会CALA分会场演讲整理*****

1. 首先, 英文图书馆与情报期刊并没有官方的1级,2级,3级之分
   

2. 某些人做了研究发表过关于期刊分级的标准如Kohl & Davis, 1985;  Nisonger & Davis, 2005; Nixon, 2012

3. 他们的研究方法大致如下:

   . 通过对美国ARL研究型图书馆学会馆长们的问卷调查(Nisonger & Dacis, 2005)

   . 设计了一些评判标准如同行评审是最关键标准, 其次专家意见(Nixson, 2012), 拒稿率, 流通量, 影响因子, 高引率等
   

   Essential criteria:
   1. peer-reviewed (or invited) titles in LIS field
   Variable criteria (a tally was given for each of these criteria)
   2. expert opinion (top rating by Deans’ list in Nisonger&Davis 2005 study)
   3. expert opinion (top rating by Directors’ list in Nisonger&Davis 2005 study)
   4. acceptance rate below 50%
   5. circulation above 5,000
   6. journals that Purdue University Libraries’ faculty members have published in more than two times in the last ten years
   7. journals with an ISI impact factor
   8. journals with an h-index above 7, as calculated using Google Scholar data
   
   

4. 普渡大学Nixson在2012年发表了Core Journals in Library and Information Science

   https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=lib_fsdocs

   根据她的研究:
   

   Tier1: 18 Titles (Nixon, 2012):
   1. Adlib Proceedings
   2. College & Research Libraries
   3. Collection Management
   4. Government Information Quarterly
   5. Information Technology and Libraries
   6. The Journal of Academic Librarianship
   7. Journal of Documentation
   8. Journal of Information Science
   9. Journal of the American Society for Information Science (title changed to (title changed to Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (JASIST))
   10. Journal of the Medical Library Association
   11. Library Collections, Acquisitions, and Technical Services
   12. Library & Information Science Research
   13. Library Journal
   14. Library Quarterly
   15. Library Resources & Technical Services
   16. Library Trends
   17. Libri
   18. RQ (title changed to Reference & User Services Quarterly)
   
   Tier 2: 37 Titles (Nixon, 2012)
   1. Archival Science
   2. Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science
   3. College & Undergraduate Libraries
   4. The Electronic Library: the international journal for the application of technology in information
   5. First Monday (Chicago)
   6. Health Information and Libraries Journal (Print)
   7. Information Development
   8. Information Processing & Management
   9. Information Research
   10. The Information Society: an international journal
   11. Informing Science
   12. Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management
   13. Interlending & Document Supply
   14. International Information and Library Review
   15. International Journal of Information Management
   16. International Journal on Digital Libraries
   17. Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship
   18. Journal of Agricultural & Food Information
   19. Journal of Business & Finance Librarianship
   20. Journal of Digital Information
   21. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science
   22. Journal of Engineering Education
   23. Journal of Information Technology
   24. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science
   25. Journal of Scholarly Publishing
   26. Knowledge Quest
   27. Law Library Journal
   28. Libraries & the Cultural Record
   29. Library Hi Tech
   30. Online Information Review
   31. Portal
   32. Program: electronic library and information systems
   33. Public Library Journal
   34. Reference Services Review
   35. Restaurator
   36. The Serials Librarian
   37. Serials Review
   

   
   

   Tier 3: 7 Titles (Nixon, 2012)
   
   1. American Libraries
   2. College & Research Libraries News
   3. D - Lib Magazine: The Magazine of Digital Library Research
   4. Information Outlook
   5. Online : Exploring Technology & Resources for Information Professionals
   6. Public Libraries
   7. School Library Journal
    

5. Reference (APA)
   Nixon, J. M. (2012). Core Journals in Library and Information Science: Developing a Methodology for Ranking LIS Journals. College & Research Libraries, 75(1), 66-90. doi:10.5860/crl12-387

   
   Nisonger, T. E., & Davis, C. H. (2005). The Perception of Library and Information Science Journals by LIS Education Deans and ARL Library Directors: A Replication of the Kohl-Davis Study. College & Research Libraries, 66(4), 341-377. doi:10.5860/crl.66.4.341