美国第二站UWM

第一篇paper顺利被adv. mater. 接受。希望下一个好消息即将到来.

Reviewer # 1

IMPORTANCE:

  2. Highly important (top 15%)

DATA OBTAINED VERIFY HYPOTHESIS AND CONCLUSIONS:

  Yes

APPROPRIATE LENGTH:

  Yes    

RECOMMEND ACCEPTANCE:

  1. Acceptable without change

Reviewer # 2

IMPORTANCE:

  1. Critically important (top 5%)

DATA OBTAINED VERIFY HYPOTHESIS AND CONCLUSIONS:

  Yes

APPROPRIATE LENGTH:

  No, the manuscript is too long

OTHER JOURNAL:

RECOMMEND ACCEPTANCE:

  2. Acceptable after minor revisions

Reviewer # 3

IMPORTANCE:

  1. Critically important (top 5%)

RECOMMEND ACCEPTANCE:

  2. Acceptable after minor revisions