我们习惯于用百度,输入“GIScience顶级期刊”的时候,看到的大抵是相同的文献。据我了解,这应该是武大资源环境学院 地理信息系统教育部重点实验室 (广告)的艾廷华老师的版本,艾老师是学院的青年才俊,人长的帅,课也讲的很好,该君有一个很重的言论“搞GIS的,做学问,不要看中文文献,要看外文 的,如果实在要看,本科生可以看一点《测绘学报》《武大学报信息版》《遥感学报》,研究生一定要看外文的”。当时记得还在想怎么在《测绘信息工程》上发处 女作,不禁倍受打击。。。。
之后也用google查过一些GIScience journal ranking之类的东西,出来的也不全,大部分都来至ISI公司的JCR,直到最近才在TGIS上看到一篇GIScience Journals Ranking and Evaluation的专业文献,于是,将其结果贴出来跟大家分享。
文章指出了片面用JCR报告的缺陷,大概就是GIScience整个学科还很弱,很多期刊刚开办不久,ISI也是商业性质引用的不一定是最好的文献等等。 这篇文章采用的方法有三种:专家打分、JCR报告、问卷调查。然后将调查的结果综合,得出了GIScience期刊的综合排名如下:
C Caron, S Roche, D Goyer and A Jaton.GIScience Journals Ranking and Evaluation: An International Delphi Study.Transactions in GIS, 2008, 12(3): 293–321
Table Final ranking of GIScience journals
Journal Rank
International Journal of Geographic Information Science
International Journal of Remote Sensing
Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing (PE&RS)
Computers and Geosciences
Transactions in GIS
GeoInformatica
Geomatica
Cartography and Geographic Information Sciences
Environment and Planning B
IEEE Transactions Geoscience and Remote Sensing
Remote Sensing of Environment
Computers, Environments and Urban Systems
Annals of the Association of American Geographers
URISA Journal
Environment and Planning A
Landscape Ecology
Cartographica
Journal of Geographic Information and Decision Analysis
Marine Geodesy
Revue Internationale de Géomatique
Geographical System
Professional Geographer
Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
Earth Surface Processus and Landforms
Progress in Human Geography
Spatial Cognition and Computation
Mapping Sciences and Remote Sensing
Canadian Journal of Remote Sensing
Cartographic Journal
Canadian Geographer
Geoscience Canada
Cybergeo
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Applied Geography
Surveying and Land Information Science
Earth Observation and Remote Sensing
Cartographic Perspectives (Journal North American Cartographic InformationSociety)
Acta Cartographica
Remote Sensing Reviews
Espace Géographique
Geofocus International Review of GI Science and Technology
Mappemonde
Geographical Analysis
Geocarto International
Geomatique Suisse
Géospatial Solutions
个人感想:虽然发在GIScience的专业期刊上,看这个排名还是要有批判的眼光,首先这个问卷调查主要在北美和欧洲范围进行,结果主要反映的也是这一 个地区,参与评判的37个专家(只有26个有回复)的国家分布,文章给出了列表,主要是在美国(10个)、法国(3个)、英国(3个)、加拿大(3个), 奥地利(2个)。这就占了21/26,亚洲国家只有日本有一个,从中可以看出文章的调查范围。无论如何,且做一个参考吧。
Journal
International Journal of Geographic Information Science
International Journal of Remote Sensing
Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing (PE&RS)
Computers and Geosciences
Transactions in GIS
GeoInformatica
Geomatica
Cartography and Geographic Information Sciences
Environment and Planning B
IEEE Transactions Geoscience and Remote Sensing
Remote Sensing of Environment
Computers, Environments and Urban Systems
Annals of the Association of American Geographers
URISA Journal
Environment and Planning A
Landscape Ecology
Cartographica
Journal of Geographic Information and Decision Analysis
Marine Geodesy
Revue Internationale de Géomatique
Geographical System
Professional Geographer
Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
Earth Surface Processus and Landforms
Progress in Human Geography
Spatial Cognition and Computation
Mapping Sciences and Remote Sensing
Canadian Journal of Remote Sensing
Cartographic Journal
Canadian Geographer
Geoscience Canada
Cybergeo
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Applied Geography
Surveying and Land Information Science
Earth Observation and Remote Sensing
Cartographic Perspectives (Journal North American Cartographic InformationSociety)
Acta Cartographica
Remote Sensing Reviews
Espace Géographique
Geofocus International Review of GI Science and Technology
Mappemonde
Geographical Analysis
Geocarto International
Geomatique Suisse
Géospatial Solutions
个人感想:虽然发在GIScience的专业期刊上,看这个排名还是要有批判的眼光,首先这个问卷调查主要在北美和欧洲范围进行,结果主要反映的也是这一 个地区,参与评判的37个专家(只有26个有回复)的国家分布,文章给出了列表,主要是在美国(10个)、法国(3个)、英国(3个)、加拿大(3个), 奥地利(2个)。这就占了21/26,亚洲国家只有日本有一个,从中可以看出文章的调查范围。无论如何,且做一个参考吧。