心在山水间分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/yatou 亲而不密 远而不疏 将科网博客进行到底!

博文

方舟子大人与肖传国罪犯言语剖析[2]

已有 6085 次阅读 2010-10-6 17:16 |个人分类:道之我观|系统分类:观点评述

http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_6bc79f2f0100n5tl.html

http://www.tudou.com/programs/view/IM4U6lJY5pc/

这样的效果与评价,还是蛮不错的嘛。外科手术能做到外方肯定评价,十分不容易啊。咱也取个“立此存照”的名头。

不过,方舟子大人新语丝那里就肖医生罪犯手术相关的“立此存照”文案是相当恐怖滴啊。

http://xys4.dxiong.com/dajia/xiaochuanguo.html

有选择性的删除,必是有选择性的选取。为啥?当然不过是为个立场呗。立场嘛 ,有公,有私, 公私各半,公大于私,私大于公,假公济私。这就得看个人的修行了。

另外,前些时日有游客朋友在我的博文中留下的英文原文是这样的:

Outcomes of Lumbar to Sacral Nerve Rerouting for Spina Bifida.
J Urol. 2010 Aug;184(2):702-7. Epub 2010 Jun 19.
Peters KM, Girdler B, Turzewski C, Trock G, Feber K, Nantau W, Bush B, Gonzalez J, Kass E, de Benito J, Diokno A.
Abstract

PURPOSE: Restoring bladder and bowel function in spina bifida by creation of a skin-central nervous system-bladder reflex arc via lumbar to sacral nerve rerouting has a reported success rate of 87% in China. We report 1-year results of the first North American trial on nerve rerouting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Nine subjects were enrolled in the study. Intradural lumbar to sacral nerve rerouting was performed. Subjects underwent urodynamic testing with stimulation of the cutaneous dermatome and careful neurological followup. Adverse events were closely monitored along with changes in bowel and bladder function.

RESULTS: At 1 year 7 patients (78%) had a reproducible increase in bladder pressure with stimulation of the dermatome. Two patients were able to stop catheterization and all safely stopped antimuscarinics. No patient achieved complete urinary continence. The majority of subjects reported improved bowel function. One patient was continent of stool at baseline and 4 were continent at 1 year. Of the patients 89% had variable weakness of lower extremity muscle groups at 1 month. One child had persistent foot drop and the remainder returned to baseline by 12 months.

CONCLUSIONS: At 1 year a novel reflex arc with stimulation of the appropriate dermatome was seen in the majority of subjects. Improvements in voiding and bowel function were noted. Lower extremity weakness was mostly self-limited, except in 1 subject with a persistent foot drop. More patients and longer followup are needed to assess the risk/benefit ratio of this novel procedure.

关于这个实验,从文摘与结果和结论来看,有以下几点需要点明:

1. 这个实验结果是正面的。还请诸位认真辨析。novel不应是译为怪异的,在化学类文献中,此词译为“新奇”的,是正面意思。此处,从效果看,也不会跑到“怪异”这样的意境中。

2.另外要注意的是,肖手术本身就是通过牺牲部分腿部神经,借用它来达到控尿的效果。足部出现一定程度的控制力削弱,如果在术前对病人交待清楚,这是没有问题的。活人总不能让尿憋死吧?

另外,感谢游客朋友提供原文。放下有色眼镜,放下自我立场,重新审视问题的勇气可喜可贺。

傻姑这两天看了一些本不想看、本没有时间与精力去看的东西,慢慢说吧。人不可为扬己名而打击别人,做事动机还是要纯正些。不要打击在中国干实事的人。如果方向出现错误,可以友善提醒。但如果象这样的做法:

http://xys4.dxiong.com/pages/dajia.html 

有点儿搞大字报的味道?

我看还是要用肖大夫罪犯的话来统一思想:

同为中国人,我们主要还是应该为他的才能和成就高兴,希望他成大器.请大家莫再穷追猛打,我给大家鞠躬了.人才难得,捧杀不好,骂杀也可惜.我更反对把事闹到哈佛当局去,内外还是应该有别,否则这石头最终会砸在所有中国学人脚上.

因为:

1:你打假的对象不是你的敌人,更不是中国人的敌人。

        2: 提倡科学和理性打假

        3:打假要重证据,要就事论事。任何人都不是真理的代表,更不是宗教裁判所的祭司。 让事实说话,是非自有公论,公道自在人心。

这三条也是肖大夫罪犯提出来的(傻姑就第二条略加修改)。

出处见http://view.news.qq.com/a/20100924/000001_1.htm

------------------------------

傻姑继续闭关。所有的问候都放在心里,祈愿朋友们平安、幸福!



https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-66009-370298.html

上一篇:持这样的观点如何?-------方舟子大人与肖传国罪犯言语剖析[1]
下一篇:游客woxing看过来
收藏 IP: .*| 热度|

41 刘全慧 鲍得海 卫军英 杨建平 孙学军 王号 王亚娟 钟炳 逄焕东 孙根年 刘艳红 吉宗祥 戴朝华 吕喆 迟菲 陈永金 吕乃基 赵宇 蔣勁松 耿文叶 李学宽 陈辉 湛韬 丛远新 焦宏远 黄锦芳 赵旭 侯振宇 christine yinglu bridgeneer tianus agreatboy hangzhou gw12921314 WC101 nm tuner wudou5 zhangzhi tubie

评论 (1 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-3-28 21:04

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部