刘实(Shi Liu) If this same standard is applied across board, there should be even more prizes/awards be revoked. Some "top" scientists that are highly appraised by the current Chinese leaders have grabbed the very high honors using their invalid discoveries published in the "top" journals which failed in applications. But I doubt their such "achievements" would even be allowed for scientific criticism. As to Fang Shimin, he is a proven emperor of plagiarism, being awarded with many prizes for his massive plagiarism.