Bobby的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/Bobby

博文

为什么二、三流人才不聘用一流人才?

已有 7531 次阅读 2018-5-14 17:35 |个人分类:科学感想|系统分类:观点评述

谢力在《一流人才的悲催境地中说:数学家哈尔莫斯在其书中《我要做数学家》说过:韦伊指出一个对数定律在起作用:一流人物吸引别的一流人物,但是二流人物往往聘用三流者,而三流人物聘用五流者。

这句话不错。不过,网上说叫韦伊学术雇佣定律(Andre Weil's law of academic hiring):

French mathematician André Weil once mentioned an unconsciousformula that weaker academic departments used when hiring new faculty. Hetold a fellow mathematician, Paul Halmos, about it and Halmos included Weil'slaw in his autobiography. Here is what Halmos says:

"But what do you do when a department [in a university]  goes bad? André Weil suggested that there is a logarithmic  law at work: first-rate people attract other first-rate people,  but second-rate people tend to hire third-raters, and third-rate  people hire fifth-raters. If a dean or a president is genuinely  interested in building and maintaining a high-quality university  (and some of them are), then he must not grant complete self-determination  to a second-rate department; he must, instead, use his administrative  powers to intervene and set things right. That's one of the proper  functions of deans and presidents, and pity the poor university  in which a large proportion of both the faculty and the administration  are second-raters; it is doomed to diverge to minus infinity."  (p. 123)

From I Want to Be a Mathematician: An Automathography, by Paul Halmos,Springer-Verlag, New York, 1984.


我探讨一下为什么二、三流人才不聘用一流人才。原因可能如下:

1、二、三流人才怕聘用到一流人才后,一流人才不服,约束不了,怕一流人才夺了他的光辉或权力,或者嫉贤妒能,怕在学术上将他自己比下去,心理上不舒服,就如同中国话所说的“武大郞开店一样”,水平比我高的人我不用。

2、也可能是二、三流人才根本就识别不出什么是一流人才。以中国目前而论,很难看出谁是一流二流,主要看以前发表的文章,有高影响因子文章就算人才,影响因子越高人才级别就越高,但天知道是导师给写的,还是谁给写的呢?再说啦,原来发表过高影响因子文章,就能断定以后也能发表高影响因子文章?当然,中国招聘不重视导师推荐,只重视文章发表情况,这也是问题所在。

3、一流人才根本就不想到二三流人才占据要津的地方。




https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-39731-1113962.html

上一篇:没有中年学术危机,只有学术资源危机
下一篇:多元宇宙理论受到重创
收藏 IP: 150.255.31.*| 热度|

19 谢力 史晓雷 王庆浩 武夷山 尤明庆 姬扬 苏力宏 蒋永华 蒋迅 鲍博 潘学峰 刘建彬 崔宗杰 姚伟 柳文山 农绍庄 李世春 puhj ncepuztf

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (24 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-4-17 07:08

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部