互联网进化论-刘锋分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/liufeng

博文

再从肖方事件谈自己对方舟子的困惑(隐藏后再发)

已有 6660 次阅读 2010-9-27 18:35 |个人分类:观点评述|系统分类:博客资讯

可以态度鲜明的说

我是支持方舟子的存在

和佩服他做的工作

事实上,我是科学网第一个发布方舟子遇袭的消息

在他妻子发布微博消息后的3分钟之后

原因是我注意到一个IT沙龙邀请方舟子两天后演讲,公布了时间和地点

我用微博短信试图提醒他注意风险,刚发完就看到了遇袭的消息

佩服之余,也谈一下自己的困惑

 

一个思考的前提是,我坚信中国不是没有世界级的科学成果和科学家

但因为中国的体制让这些人被压制和信息屏蔽了

我也坚信中国的中医经过几千年的磨练和积累

能在中国存在,一定有他的意义所在

 

方舟子打假打的令人淋漓畅快,甚至被世界重要媒体关注

但是十几年来,方舟子对于中国本土的具有重要意义的科学成果

有过同样的关注和帮助传播么?

我没有看到,

一味的打击和摧毁

对他的国家(方说他还是中国国籍)

里的人民给与任何正面意义的提升和帮助么?

打击中医,打击院士,打击教授,打击企业家

的确,被打的往往是因为自己有裂缝,也的确应该被打

但这些群体里优秀的,有价值的人和事

方利用自己的影响力,正面传播了么

十几年里,不知有没有案例,

如果没有,我会在敬佩中困惑

 

肖传国教授的治疗率是个可量化,可检验的事实

几年的较量,媒体偏向对肖并不有利,

而且肖的反应如此激烈甚至偏激,也很容易让同情票给了方舟子

包括我在内,

但忽然间,也有了一个疑惑

也许真的因为追求商业利益,治疗案例数据有了水分

但肖式反射弧在理论上和实践上有重要的科学价值么?

如果有的话,方舟子是不是用一个漏洞和缺失摧毁一个中国本土有科学意义的成果

 

所有这些,我感到困惑,我也相信方舟子会看到我的文章

因为两个月前,我的一篇科学网博文就被转到新语丝里

有可能,希望自己的困惑能得到解答

 



“肖氏反射弧”争议
https://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-39263-367548.html

上一篇:肖氏反射弧决定方舟子的历史地位
下一篇:到底谁是互联网的爸爸?
收藏 IP: .*| 热度|

21 姜念云 曹俊兴 武夷山 刘洋 李小文 王桂颖 鲍得海 曹聪 陈苏华 赵福国 迟菲 蔣勁松 虞左俊 丛远新 罗军 赵旭 zy88093139 侯振宇 zhj71626 yinglu zhaowanfu

发表评论 评论 (17 个评论)

IP: 130.219.8.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [11][濞撶ǹ顓筣濞撶ǹ顓�   2010-10-19 22:01
闁絼绨虹拠纾嬪€撮悽銊よ厬閸ユ垝姹夐崑姘毈閻т粙绱堕惃鍕焹鐟封偓閸欘垯浜掓导鎴犵厽閵嗭拷

娑撳娼伴弰顖濆€撮崷锟�1999楠炵骞忓妤冩畱NIH Grant閻ㄥ嫭鎲崇憰渚婄礉閸欘垯浜掗惇瀣毉閸︺劍顒濇稊瀣娴犳牔绗夋禒鍛嚒缂佸繐婀紘搴℃禇閸嬫俺绻冮崝銊у⒖鐠囨洟鐛欓敍宀冣偓灞肩瑬娴犳牞绻曢崑姘崇箖娴滐拷14娓氬姊炬禍鎭掆偓锟�

http://www.researchgrantdatabase.com/g/5R01DK053063-05/SKIN-CNS-BLADDER-REFLEX-ARC-FOR-MICTURITION-AFTER-SCI/

SKIN-CNS-BLADDER REFLEX ARC FOR MICTURITION AFTER SCI

Chuan-guo Xiao
New York University School Of Medicine New York, Ny 10016

Grant 5R01DK053063-05 from National Institute Of Diabetes And Digestive And Kidney Diseases IRG: ZRG1

Abstract: The neurological bladder caused by spinal cord injury (SCI) presents a significant medical and social problem. There is no satisfactory treatment yet. Supported by the Paralyzed Veterans of America and NIH, a new reflex pathway, "Skin-CNS-Bladder" for controlled micturition after SCI has been successfully established in rat, cat and canine models. Preliminary clinical application of 14 SCI patients also provided very promising results. The study proposed here is to transfer the Skin-CNS-Bladder reflex functions. The ventral root (VR) of a lumbar nerve (L5) below the spinal cord lesion will be anastomosed to the sacral VR (S2 and/or S3) which innervate the bladder, while leaving the intact L5 dorsal root (DR) as a started of micturition. After the axonal regeneration, controllable voiding would be initiated by scratching the L4 dermatome. Effect of the new reflex pathway on bladder function will be evaluated by means of electrophysiology and urodynamics. Its effect on bowel and sexual functions will also be studied. The procedure may revolutionize the treatment of neurogenic bladder after SCI, It requires relatively minor surgery on 2 paralyzed nerves. It does not involve implantation of electrodes or other devices but provides unique voluntary control of bladder emptying. Scientifically, the study will further prove the new concept derived from the unique somatic-autonomic reflex that the impulses delivered from the efferent neurons of a somatic reflex arc may be transferred to initiate response of an autonomic effector. This new concept may be widely useful, not only for neurogenic bladder, but also for other problems caused by the spinal cord injury or diseases.

Keywords: electrophysiology, human therapy evaluation, neurogenic urinary bladder disorder, neuroregulation, neurosurgery, somatic reflex, spinal cord injury, urination, central nervous system, clinical trial, functional ability, outcomes research, quality of life, skin, urinary electronic stimulator, clinical research, human subject

Project start date: 1999-09-30

Project end date: 2007-12-31

5R01DK053063-05 (2004): $642796
IP: 69.117.13.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [10][濞撶ǹ顓筣濞撶ǹ顓�   2010-10-19 09:16
13濡よ壈绻栫粔宥嗗壖娑撳秴褰查崣濠勬畱娴滃搫鐤勯崷銊唨娴滃搫褰堟稉宥勭啊.閼叉牜娈戦幍瀣钩閺冣晛姘ㄩ崑姘崇箖娴滃棗濮╅悧鈺佺杽妤狅拷,娑撴潙绨ョ拠鏇㈢崣,楠炴湹琚卞▎锛勭病閸ヨ棄顔嶉柎鏉戠暰鐞氼偅澹掗崙鍡曠埃娴犮儲甯归獮锟�,鏉╃偠绻栨稉顏呮付閸╃儤婀伴惃鍕皑鐎圭偤鍏樻稉鈧弮鐘冲閻拷,鐏炲懐鍔х亸杈ㄦ降閺勭偓鎲滄禒鏍亝閼层儱銇囬惃鍕韫囷拷.

婵″倹鐏夋担鐘哄窛閻ゆ垵娴楃€瑰爼澹岀€规碍婀侀梻顕€顣�,閸欘垯浜�,娴e棝鍋呴弰顖氬綗婢舵牔绔存稉顏堟6妫帮拷,婢堆冾啀閸欘垯浜掗幗鍡曠皑鐎圭偠顔夐柆鎾舵倞缂佈呯敾鐠併劏顔�.閸欘垯缍樻潻鐐茬唨閺堫剛娈戦幆鍛枌闁垝绗夋禍鍡毿�,鐏忚鲸娼甸崣鎴c€冩担鐘垫畱妤傛ǹ顫�,鐏炴洜銇氭担鐘垫畱閼诡垰绺�,闁絼绗夐弰顖滅懅鐠囨繀绠�?

娑擃厼娴楁潻娆庨嚋缁€鍙ョ窗,鐎圭偛婀弰顖涙¥閻儳娈戦幇姘毌婢额亜顦�,闁姵鍨氭潻娆愮壉閻ㄥ嫬鐪棃锟�,婵帊缍嬮張澶夌瑝閸欘垱甯归崡鍝ユ畱鐠愶絼鎹�.
IP: 113.142.233.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [9]jihua0a   2010-10-15 12:25
缂囧骸娴楁禍楦跨槑娴犵柉鍊存导鐘叉禇閻ㄥ嫭澧滈張锟�
鐟欎弓ttp://video.sina.com.cn/v/b/38888027-1808244527.html
IP: 202.113.9.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [8]goudan1   2010-10-13 16:50
閹殿垱璐�,閼叉牕鐨箛鍛淬€忕紒蹇氱箖閸斻劎澧�,娴滆桨缍嬬€圭偤鐛欓崥搴¤嫙閼惧嘲鍣幍宥堝厴鎼存梻鏁ゆ禍搴″鞍閻わ拷,娴犲骸鐣犵悰灞艰礋閸欘垯浜掔€瑰苯鍙忛弰搴f鐎瑰啳鍓崇€涙劙鍣烽崫顏呮箒閸掝偂姹夊缁樻た,閼存垵鐡欓柌灞炬Ц闂勩垹锛�, 閹峰じ绗夐崚浼存珜婢诡偄姘ㄦ担婊勫竴绾板秳绨ㄩ惃鍕眽,
IP: 210.77.95.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [7]闂勮泛顨�   2010-10-13 08:50
閼板啿鎯�
閻壈顫�
娑撳秴鎯�
娑撳秷顫�
IP: 218.199.39.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [6]鐠佸憡绂嬫潻锟�   2010-10-13 05:43
閸氬本鍓扮純鎴濆几wc101閻ㄥ嫮婀呭▔鏇窗閺傜鍨风€涙劕婀幍鎾充海閻ㄥ嫰妫舵0妯圭瑐閳ユ粈绨╅崗顐㈢磻閳ユ繃鍨ㄩ垾婊€绗佹稉鍐ㄧ磻閳ユ繐绱濋崝鐔惰礋娑撴眹鈧拷
IP: 218.199.39.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [5]鐠佸憡绂嬫潻锟�   2010-10-13 05:42
閺傜鍨风€涙劕婀幍鎾充海閻ㄥ嫰妫舵0妯圭瑐閳ユ粈绨╅崗顐㈢磻閳ユ繃鍨ㄩ垾婊€绗佹稉鍐ㄧ磻閳ユ繐绱濋崝鐔惰礋娑撴眹鈧拷
IP: 123.151.32.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [4]tuner   2010-10-12 23:02
閹存垼绻栨稉顏勵樆鐞涘瞼鎮婄憴锝呭冀鐏忓嫬濮敍锟�

閹綀鈧懏婀抽崜宥呯暚閸忋劍鐥呴張澶嬪笓鐏忔寧鍔呯憴澶涚礉闂団偓鐟曚礁鐣鹃弮鑸靛皨閸樺鍚傞柈銊﹀笓鐏忚¥鈧倽绻栨导姘辩舶閸愬懓鍓伴崳銊ョ暭闁姵鍨氬鍫濐樋闂傤噣顣介妴锟�

閹恒儰绨¢崣宥呯殸瀵冩倵閿涘瞼鏁ら崚鐑樼负婢堆嗗悪閻喛鍋嗛惃鍕濞夋洑鍞弴澶哥啊閹搞倕甯囬懙褰掑劥閹烘帒缈遍妴鍌滄暠娴滃骸鐣犻惄瀛樺复娴f粎鏁ゆ禍搴ゅ敤閼宠京娈戠粊鐐电病缁崵绮洪敍灞煎▏瀵版鍞ㄩ懗杈ㄦ暪缂傗晪绱濈亸鍧椾壕閹垫挸绱戦敍灞肩瑝瑜板崬鎼烽崗璺虹暊閸c劌鐣奸妴鍌炴珟濮濄倛鈧苯顦婚敍灞芥礈娑撹桨鑵戦弸銏㈩殻缂佸繐鑻熷▽鈩冨复闁熬绱濋惀鍛眽鏉╂ɑ妲告稉宥勭窗閺堝缈遍幇鐕傜礉娑撳秴鐣鹃弮鑸靛笓鐏忚法娈戠拠婵撶礉閼垛偓閼宠鲸寮ф禍鍡曠矝閻掓湹绱伴張澶婄勘娑撳秷鍤滄稉缁樺笓閸戞亽鈧拷

閸欏秴鐨犲褔娓剁憰浣风濞堝灚妞傞梻瀛樺闂€鎸庡灇閿涘苯鍩″┑鈧惃顔垮亞閹烘帒缈辨潻娆戭潚閻楄鐣╅惃鍕煙濞夋洑绡冮棁鈧憰浣筋唲缂佸啨鈧倹澧嶆禒銉礉閹恒儰绨¢崣宥呯殸瀵冨祮娴f寧鍨氶崝鐕傜礉閹綀鈧懐娈戦幒鎺戠勘娴犲秶鍔ф稉搴㈩劀鐢晲姹夐張澶婄发婢堆傜瑝閸氬矉绱濋幒鎺戠勘閻ㄥ嫭鏅ラ弸婊€绡冩导姘箒瀹割喖绱撻妴鍌涘鐠嬫挴鈧粏鍤滄稉缁樺笓鐏忓簱鈧繐绱濈亸杈ㄦЦ閸︺劍鐥呴張澶婄勘閹板繒娈戦幆鍛枌娑撳瀵岄崝銊ョ暰閺冭埖甯撶亸瑁も偓锟�
IP: 166.111.107.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [3]閽勶絽濯弶锟�   2010-10-12 21:51
jiangjinsong鐏忓棙鍋嶉惃鍕瀮缁旂姵甯归柅浣稿煂娴犵増婀滈弰鐔衡敄,
IP: 221.239.91.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [2]閼斥€充淮濞夛拷   2010-10-12 21:01
閻绨¢柧鐐复闁插瞼娈戠悰銊︾壐閿涘苯绶㈤弮鐘侯嚔閵嗗倷缍橀崗鍫濆箵閻婀呴弬瑙勬Ц閹簼绠炵憴锝夊櫞濞屸剝婀佹稉鈧笟瀣灇閸旂喓娈戦妴锟�
IP: 221.239.91.*   | 鐠э拷 鐠э拷 +1 [1]閼斥€充淮濞夛拷   2010-10-12 20:39
閺傚綊鍋呮潏纭咁嚛濞屸剝婀佹稉鈧笟瀣灇閸旂噦绱濋懓宀冨€存潻娆掔珶鐠囷拷80%閵嗗倷琚遍懓鍛祲瀹割喗鐎径褋鈧倹妫﹂悞鎯板€撮張澶婂帠鐡掑磭娈戠粔鎴犵埡缂佸繗鍨傞敍灞界紦鐠侇喛鍊寸€佃澧嶉張澶屾⒕娴滆櫣娈戦幍瀣钩鐟欏棝顣剁€涙ɑ銆傞敍鍫濆讲娴犮儰绮犻悳鏉挎躬瀵偓婵绱氶敍娑欐付閸氬骸鐨㈤懗钘夘檮閹垫儳鍩岄惃鍕⒕娴滄椽鍏橀幍鎯у煂閿涘瞼绮烘稉鈧崚鏉垮娴滎剛鈥樼拋銈忕礉閻╅晲淇婃稉杞扮啊鏉╂瑤娆㈡禍瀣剰閼猴拷100娑撳洣浜掓稉濠勬畱瀹割喗姊剧拹纭呯箷閺勵垰鈧厧绶遍惃鍕┾偓鍌涙¥鐠嬫挸鍟€娴犮儱澧犻柇锝勭疄婢舵艾鍕鹃柇锝嗙壉閸氬吀绗呴崢璁崇啊閵嗭拷

閸楁矮瀵岄崶鐐差槻閿涙碍鏌熼柇锝堢珶閻ㄥ嫭鍋呴懓鍛扮殶閺屻儴銆冮崷銊ㄧ箹闁插矉绱濇担鐘哄殰瀹歌京婀呴敍姝╰tp://www.sciencenet.cn/m/user_content.aspx?id=368948

1/1 | 閹槒顓�:11 | 妫f牠銆� | 娑撳﹣绔存い锟� | 娑撳绔存い锟� | 閺堫偊銆� | 鐠哄疇娴�

扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2025-2-19 13:21

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007-2025 中国科学报社

返回顶部