Is the work understandable and correct?

•   Is it clear what the authors are trying to achieve?

•   Are there sufficient references to provide background and put the work in context?

•   Are the results backed up with evidence? Are there any unsupported claims?

•   Is the work correct? Are there any errors, flaws or mistakes in the manuscript?

•   Are the mathematics or statistics correct?

•   Do you understand the work?

Is the work novel and interesting?

•   Are the results interesting?

•   Is the research important? Do the authors explain why it is important or how it advances our understanding of the field?

•   Is the work original? Does it contain new material? Have any parts of the manuscript been published before?

•   How relevant is this work to researchers in your field? Would it be beneficial to get an opinion from a researcher in another field?

•   Is this only an incremental advance over previous work?

Is the work well presented?

•   Does the title reflect the contents of the article?

•   Does the abstract contain the essential information of the article?

•   Are the figures and tables correct and informative? Are there too many, or too few?

•   Does the conclusion summarize what has been learned and why it is interesting and useful?

•   Is it clear?

•   Is the manuscript an appropriate length?