waterlilyqd的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/waterlilyqd 翻译--编辑--信息分析从平凡中见神奇! Journal of Mountain Science科学网博客

博文

审稿人推荐的参考文献都要请作者加上吗?

已有 6533 次阅读 2013-8-23 12:25 |个人分类:科技杂谈|系统分类:观点评述|关键词:参考文献,,同行评审| 参考文献, 同行评审

       很多时候, 审稿人审稿后会认为作者在文献综述和讨论部分写得不好,文献综述可能只综述了作者自己本国的文献或者很多重要的文献没有在综述中提到, 在讨论部分只局限于本文所得结果的讨论, 视野不够开阔, 没有将研究结果与国内外相关研究作对比分析, 因此, 审稿人会建议作者阅读和引用审稿人列出的其它文献.

       有些审稿人的建议非常好, 推荐作者阅读的文献也恰如其分,即使是审稿人自己的文章或者自己团队的文章,如果与所审稿件的内容直接相关,这无可厚非。如果审稿人推荐作者引用的文献不完全是从文章本身出发,而是为了提高审稿人自己和自己团队的论文的被引频次,或者是为了提高(审稿人做主编或者编委或者是编辑)某一期刊的被引频次,这种推荐就会有审稿人在滥用权力的嫌疑。

      在将审稿人的意见发给作者之前,编辑人员需要认真地分析审稿人的推荐意见,以便作出正确的判断和向作者提出合理的建议,当然作者也可以根据自己的理解,酌情考虑审稿人推荐引用的文献。

       下面是一份审稿意见的示例。在此,不便讨论审稿人是否滥用职权,但就从审稿人推荐作者引用的10多篇文章基本上都是审稿人自己的文章和审稿人作为编辑的那个期刊的文章来看,这份审稿意见是需要认真分析的。  

____________________________________

Dear author,
In my opinion your paper needs a general introduction that will show that there is an interaction of vegetation and erosion
Plants can control the soil losses, and usually we measured the plant cover.
See some examples
Cerdà, A., Doerr, S. 2005 The influence of vegetation recovery on soil hydrology and erodibility following fire: an eleven-year research. International Journal of Wildland Fire 14(4): 423-437 *pdf http://dx.doi.org/10.1071/WF05044
Cerdà, A. 1998. The influence of aspect and vegetation on seasonal changes in erosion under rainfall simulation on a clay soil in Spain. Canadian Journal of Soil Science, 78, 321-330.
And the interaction between vegetation and erosion
Cerdà, A. & P. García-Fayos, P. 2002. The influence of seed size and shape on their removal by water erosion. Catena, 48, 293-301.

Vegetation also play a key role on landslides, and there is where roots play a key role,
This is what you should highlight in your introduction that should have a broad view.

See this

A. J. Miller 2013 ASSESSING LANDSLIDE SUSCEPTIBILITY BY INCORPORATING THE SURFACE COVER INDEX AS A MEASUREMENT OF VEGETATIVE COVER
LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT
Volume 24, Issue 3, May/June 2013, Pages: 205–227, DOI: 10.1002/ldr.1115

G. B. Douglas, I. R. Mcivor, A. K. Manderson, J. P. Koolaard, M. Todd, S. Braaksma and R. A. J. Gray 2013 REDUCING SHALLOW LANDSLIDE OCCURRENCE IN PASTORAL HILL COUNTRY USING WIDE-SPACED TREES LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT Volume 24, Issue 2, March/April 2013, Pages: 103–114, , DOI: 10.1002/ldr.1106

P. Raska, J. Klimes and J. Dubisar 2013
USING LOCAL ARCHIVE SOURCES TO RECONSTRUCT HISTORICAL LANDSLIDE OCCURRENCE IN SELECTED URBAN REGIONS OF THE CZECH REPUBLIC: EXAMPLES FROM REGIONS WITH DIFFERENT HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT DOI: 10.1002/ldr.2192

G. B. Douglas, I. R. Mcivor, A. K. Manderson, J. P. Koolaard, M. Todd, S. Braaksma and R. A. J. Gray 2013 REDUCING SHALLOW LANDSLIDE OCCURRENCE IN PASTORAL HILL COUNTRY USING WIDE-SPACED TREES LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT Volume 24, Issue 2, March/April 2013, Pages: 103–114, , DOI: 10.1002/ldr.1106
And this is because there a clear relationship between soil erosion and vegetation cover


Pasquale Borrelli, Michael Märker and Brigitta Schütt 2013. MODELLING POST-TREE-HARVESTING SOIL EROSION AND SEDIMENT DEPOSITION POTENTIAL IN THE TURANO RIVER BASIN (ITALIAN CENTRAL APENNINE) LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT, DOI: 10.1002/ldr.2214

J. Lieskovský and P. Kenderessy 2012 MODELLING THE EFFECT OF VEGETATION COVER AND DIFFERENT TILLAGE PRACTICES ON SOIL EROSION IN VINEYARDS: A CASE STUDY IN VRÁBLE (SLOVAKIA) USING WATEM/SEDEM LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT DOI: 10.1002/ldr.2162

And this is why vegetation is use for recovering degraded slopes


LAND DEGRADATION AND DEVELOPMENT
Sérgio Alegre Prats, Maruxa Cortizo Malvar, Diana Catarina Simões Vieira, Lee MacDonald and Jan Jacob Keizer 2013 EFFECTIVENESS OF HYDROMULCHING TO REDUCE RUNOFF AND EROSION IN A RECENTLY BURNT PINE PLANTATION IN CENTRAL PORTUGAL LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT DOI: 10.1002/ldr.2236

I also suggest to include some coments to the fungi contribution to stabilize the soil

K. Burri, C. Gromke and F. Graf 2013 MYCORRHIZAL FUNGI PROTECT THE SOIL FROM WIND EROSION: A WIND TUNNEL STUDY
LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT Volume 24, Issue 4, July/August 2013, Pages: 385–392, DOI: 10.1002/ldr.1136

 



http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-314423-718153.html

上一篇:投稿Journal of Mountain Science 后什么时候能够知道结果?
下一篇:Manuscript handling procedure (Journal of Mountain Science)

1 何学锋

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (2 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备14006957 )

GMT+8, 2019-1-16 08:00

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部