IMPORTANCE: 1. Critically important (top 5%) DATA OBTAINED VERIFY HYPOTHESIS AND CONCLUSIONS: Yes APPROPRIATE LENGTH: Yes OTHER JOURNAL:
RECOMMEND ACCEPTANCE:
1. Acceptable without change
COMMENTS: One of bottlenecks of metallic glasses is applications. This paper presents interesting results using unique properties (outstanding efficiency of Fe-based metallic glass powders in degrading organic water contaminants) of metallic glass for the application. The authors have demonstrated and compared that the metallic glass has better chemical performance than the commercial one. They show that metastable thermodynamic nature and the particle surface topography are the major factors controlling the chemical performance of the metallic glass. Their findings may open a new opportunity for functional applications of metallic glasses. The paper is well written and the results are very interesting not only in metallic glass filed. I think the paper fit well of the requirements of Adv. Func. Mater. I then recommend the publications.